Sheffield Christmas Market beats Leeds in UK rankings with top marks for reviews and value

Sheffield has ranked far and above Leeds in a UK study of the best Christmas markets.

The Christmas Market Index 2025 by travel tips website Locals Insider ranked Sheffield in 10th place, beating Winchester, Oxford, Nottingham and, most importantly, city rival Leeds, which came 19th.

Sheffield Christmas Market has ranked 10th in the UK in a in-house study by Locals Insiderplaceholder image
Sheffield Christmas Market has ranked 10th in the UK in a in-house study by Locals Insider

The in-house studies assessed festive markets on seven factors – annual visitors, number of stalls, duration, online reviews, accessibility, setting and cost – to determine which was the best all-round destination to get in the Christmas spirit.

Local Insider scored points based on:

- Annual visitors – 1 point for every 200,000 annual visitors

- Stalls – 1 point for every 20 stalls

- Online reviews – Google review (out of 5) multiplied by 2

- Costs – which it called "definitely the trickiest one," by looking at local hotel prices and the price of a traditional market basket (mulled wine, bratwurst, small gift).

- Duration – 1 point for every 5 days

Sheffield’s market was particularly praised for affordability (12/15) and duration (9.6/12), offering visitors a full season of activity without the high price tag seen in southern markets such as London’s Winter Wonderland or Bath.

However, the city scored lower for market size (5.4/18) and visitor numbers (2.4/12), suggesting that while Sheffield provides “a relaxed and community-focused atmosphere”, it doesn’t yet draw the same nationwide crowds as bigger markets. For example, while Sheffield sees around 500,000 visits a year, Edinburgh, Manchester and Birmingham top over two million.

Meanwhile, Leeds was rated as attracting less than half of what Sheffield pulls and scored worse for duration (7.2), reviews (7.8), and setting (7.2), with an overall score of 47.8 to Sheffield’s 58.6.

Meanwhile, the clear UK winner was the legendary Christmas markets of Edinburgh, which scored 79.7, followed by London’s Winter Wonderland (79) and Manchester (78.8).

Spokesperson for Locals Insider, Martin Danemaq, said: “Sheffield’s Christmas market continues to offer one of the most welcoming festive experiences in Yorkshire, combining great value with a strong local feel.

“The research shows there’s more than one way to do Christmas well. While cities like Edinburgh and London dominate with scale and spectacle, markets such as Sheffield prove that a warm local atmosphere and affordability can make just as lasting an impression.”

The rankings are as follows:

CityRankingAnnual VisitorsStallsDurationReviewsAccessSettingCostOverall Score
Edinburgh#1125.41210.281814.179.7
London (Winter Wonderland)#21218128.8816.2479
Manchester#3121810.86.9812.610.578.8
Birmingham#41218125.41014.44.576.3
Glasgow#53.616.210.88.1810.81269.5
Bath#62.4183.69.31012.610.566.4
Belfast#7698.412.987.21263.5
York#87.27.28.412.987.21263.5
Newcastle#99.63.68.45.1812.61259.3
Sheffield#102.45.49.611.4710.81258.6
Winchester#111.210.87.29.3612.610.557.6
..............................
Leeds#191.25.47.27.877.21247.8

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice