Sheffield’s best Italian restaurants have gained an enthusiastic following for their pizza and pasta dishes, with some receiving more than 800 positive reviews online.
The following nine restaurants have not only earned a reputation for their quality dishes, but for atmosphere, service, and value for money.
All of the below are reliably good dining experiences, each with a minimum of 75 reviews. A special mention should still be given to Risto-Deli 2 Terre, which has 22 reviews averaging at a 5-star Google rating.
Rosmarino and Dino’s also deserve an honorary mention, with their respective 43 and 16 reviews earning them each an average rating of 4.9.
Whether you like a classic Margherita, creamy carbonara or a hearty osso buco, the following popular Sheffield restaurants are sure to satisfy your cravings.
- RELATED: £400k Sheffield home is a refurbishment project with big potential
- RELATED: Throwback to nights out partying in Sheffield in early 2000s
- RELATED: What you can expect as Black Owned Markets returns to Cutlery Works
- RELATED: The Sheffield suburb named one of the "coolest neighbourhoods in the UK"

5. Olive
Over on Ecclesall Road, the affordable and delicious Mediterranean and Italian food at the family-run business has won it a 4.8 rating on Google, from 241 customer reviews. | Google

6. Paesani
Paesani in Crookes continues to build a strong positive reputation for its handmade pizzas. The restaurant is in a perfect spot for a summer evening takeaway at Bole Hill. From 304 customer reviews, it has a 4.8 rating. | Google

7. Kia's Pasteria
Our third Abbeydale Road establishment to make the list is Kia's, which has the second-highest number of reviews: 430, averaging a 4.8 rating. Kia's notably does not serve pizza, but is "all the better for it" according to reviews. Another says it is the "best Italian they have had outside of Italy". A strong contender for the top Italian spot in Sheffield. | Google

8. Food Target
Of its relatively modest number of 75 reviews, only three give Food Target less than 5 stars, leaving it with an impressive rating of 4.9, just pipping to the post the other Abbeydale Road Italians on the list. Reviews mention fantastic pizza and friendly service, for both dining in and taking away. | Google


