We asked our readers which pubs they remember as being the city’s roughest back in the day.
These were some of the pubs named the most, including the Cannon and Magnet pubs.
Now, there is no authority on what is a ‘rough pub’ - what is ‘rough’ to one punter is to another a watering hole full of characters.
As Jacqueline Richardson put it: “The roughest ones were the best ones to go in. Real people with real lives and problems but the best people to have a laugh with. What you see is what you got.”
How many of these pubs did you visit? What did you hear that cemented it as one of Sheffield’s rough pubs, or maybe marked it as one of the ‘good ones’ in your books?

5. The Scottish Queen
The old Scottish Queen pub, on South Street, at Sheffield's Park Hill flats, is pictured here in 1985. It was once one of Sheffield's roughest pubs, according to Sarah Louise Simcox, who said it was her local while she lived on Norwich Row. | Picture Sheffield Photo: Picture Sheffield

6. The Highway
The Highway pub, on Fox Street, Pitsmoor, is pictured here in 1991. The pub, built in around 1963, was nominated by Andrew Gamban as one of Sheffield's roughest boozers from years gone by. | Picture Sheffield Photo: Picture Sheffield

7. Market Tavern
The old Market Tavern pub, originally Rotherham House, is pictured here on Exchange Street, Sheffield city centre, in 1987. It was nominated as one of Sheffield's roughest pubs by Lisa Briggs, along with the Cannon. But she added 'loved em never a dull moment'. The Market Tavern was controversially demolished in January 2024. | Picture Sheffield Photo: Picture Sheffield

8. The Springwood
The Springwood pub, on Hastilar Road South, Woodthorpe, was Nasser Alowyairi's choice as Sheffield's roughest pub. But he said he 'loved it' and there were 'some proper people in it'. | Picture Sheffield/Douglas Edward Axe/Brian Douglas Stevens Photo: Picture Sheffield/Douglas Edward Axe/Brian Douglas Stevens


