The price that needs paying as the cost of ‘cool’ stacks up for Crookes community

The growing success and ‘coolness’ of Crookes has a hidden cost accredited to rising rents.

Crookes has been recently ranked the UK's sixth coolest neighbourhood by Time Out magazine.

This title has brought a lot of pride to the area, however, some fear that Crookes label of cool could bring consequences, driving up rents and pricing out the very community that makes it special. 

Owner of Small Plants and founder of Crookes Collective, Ellon Wattplaceholder image
Owner of Small Plants and founder of Crookes Collective, Ellon Watt | Own Photo

MP for Sheffield Hallam, Olivia Blake branded the title as ‘well deserved’ and described Crookes as a 15-minute neighbourhood.

Ms Blake said: “Since the pandemic, people want more stuff in their local neighbourhood.

“The community within Crookes plays a big part in its success.”

PM, Andy Burnham said a measure of success is the local high street, saying: "People don't measure growth by looking at a spreadsheet.

Just Natural, a produce shop in Crookes.placeholder image
Just Natural, a produce shop in Crookes. | Own Photo

"They measure it by looking at their local high street."

Crookes councillors, Minesh Parekh and Ruth Milsom feel the success of Crookes is down to its diverse misture of residents.

Coun Milsom said: "The slant taken in Time Out was very much about the businesses and the cool cafes.

“I think what’s equally cool is the mix of people who live there.”

Owner of Crookes Hardware, Richardplaceholder image
Owner of Crookes Hardware, Richard | Own Photo

Coun Parekh added: “Crookes has developed over so many years into its own distinct place, and I think it’s growing in that way because people clearly want it to grow in that way."

However, the growing success and ‘coolness’ of Crookes has a hidden cost accredited to rising rents.

Coun Parekh said: "Landlords can get away with charging more because of a certain postcode, or, unfortunately, an area being seen as cool.”

Owner of Crookes Hardware, Richard, expressed the greatest problem he faces as a small business owner is the cost of rent.

He said: "My rent since I first moved here 16 years ago has gone up £200 a month, and it’s a lot of money to find each time.

"My income hasn’t gone up by that much every month, so it's coming out of my pocket."

Crookes Councillors Minesh Parekh and Ruth Milsom in the Council Chamber at Sheffield Town Hallplaceholder image
Crookes Councillors Minesh Parekh and Ruth Milsom in the Council Chamber at Sheffield Town Hall | Own photo

Owner of Small Plants, Ellon Watt, founded Crookes Collective, a group of independent businesses funded through the council’s Economic Recovery Fund.

The collective has worked to improve Crookes by adding street art, installing seating and planting a community orchard.

The fund ran between 2021 and 2025, aiming to support economic recovery on local high streets while rents crept up.

Rising rents have also affected residents of Crookes like 35-year-old Orla who said: “Rents and house prices have risen since 2020.

“We ended up buying a house that was nearly falling down because it’s really hard to afford a house around here.”

Alongside rent, over the past few years Crookes has seen a rise in cafes, bringing an influx of customers to the area.

Crumb employee Jed said: "At weekends it's non-stop from doors open until about 1 o'clock.

"There's queues out the door."

However, owner of Crookes Hardware, Richard, feels the area has become too dominated by coffee-shop culture.

He said: “A high street can’t survive on cafes alone, but they seem to be the only places that are surviving.”

While many locals are welcoming their title as the UK’s sixth ‘coolest neighbourhood’, some fear it could accelerate gentrification, pricing out residents and compromising the area’s identity.  

Jacob, 28, said: "As the place gets popular, it's going to attract more people and could potentially affect its value but hopefully they’ll find a way to balance it."

For the owner of Small Plants, Crookes' appeal goes further than its newfound reputation.

Ms Watt: “‘Cool’ has the inflection that the trend will pass, whereas I think Crookes is more long-lasting.”

As Crookes' popularity continues to grow, the question remains whether it can hold onto the community-feel that put it on the map in the first place.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice