We visited a Sheffield garden bakery that is taking on the big boys at the British Pie Awards
This small, competent, but quietly confident Sheffield bakery is aiming for top marks in the British Pie Awards, so we went along to see how this garden-based kitchen is taking it to the big boys.
The pie is one of the staples of British menus and could be one of the country’s most important contributions to international cuisine.
Savoury or sweet, hot or cold, the British eat millions of them every year worth over £1billion in total.


Now, a small-scale Sheffield business, Windsors Bakery Ltd has entered a solitary pie into this year’s British Pie Awards, in the hope of winning a Gold, Silver or Bronze and possibly even Class Winner, in what has been called the Olympics of the Pie World.
The awards are an annual national celebration of British Pies in all their varieties and they have been running since 2009.
But here’s something that’s different about Windsors’ Bakery, it’s not a large conglomerate, pastry business endeavour or anything else with huge financial backing behind it. This is a small independent family run bakery, where everything is baked from within a small outhouse-like structure, converted into a miniature bakery.


Many of us wouldn’t think of turning part of our garden into a bakery. Installing a BBQ or a smoker sure, but not an actual bakery. This is precisely what the husband and wife team powering Windsor’s Bakery have done.
On a decidedly dour and rainy afternoon, I ventured to a household a mere stone’s throw from Crystal Peaks where I met the man with the plan, Jack Windsor, who took me through a brief history of their bakery business as well as their hopes of winning big at the British Pie Awards.


“We set this up three years ago to offer pies to the local area, whether it’s two pies or two hundred pies, we offer a wide range of flavours – Including bespoke fillings too,” he says.
“We’ve got over 20-years of catering experience between the two of us, we’ve even won a few awards along the way.”
Jack has been the recipient of the Young Chef of the Year in Sheffield twice now, so it’s fair to say that when it comes to cooking across a variety of styles he certainly knows his way around a kitchen.
With over 16-years of experience on his own part, Jack had this to say about their pies.
“We know what we’re doing and we even seem to have got the pastry down to a fine art as well.”
As if on cue, he turns around and produces a pie he’d baked earlier and proceeds to slice the pie down the middle, having been left to cool briefly while before I arrived. It's heartening to see a filling that elicits not a single word but merely a nod of appreciation and respect. It’s clear that the Windsor’s know how to make a quality pie.
“This one has been baked for around 35 minutes, and customers receive this pie frozen. It comes with all of the labels and allergens on there too,” he explains.
“But the pastry is raw when you get the pie, that’s our little USP (unique selling point), so when you cook it at home you get the first cook of the pastry. So you’ll get the best bang for your buck”, or a few quid.
The pie in question is chicken and mushroom, with decently sized chunks of chicken embalmed in a thick and creamy mushroom sauce.
“There’s also a little bit of mustard in there”, Jack adds as I take the first bite, “You can even do it in the air-fryer, it takes around 35-40 minutes if you do it in the air fryer.
Too busy taking in the bevy of flavours, it’s immediately noticeable that the chicken is both chunky and tender. Maintaining moisture without absorbing the creamy mushroom filling. The hint of mustard lingers in the back, clearly there but not at all intrusive or overwhelming. The pastry is both firm, yet flakes perfectly with each bite. Sometimes when you take a bite out of a pie it can crumble and fall apart… but this does not, it maintains its structure and is a delight. Conclusion, a cracking pie.
While I tuck into the remaining morsels Jack tells me about Windsor’s entrant into the British Pie Awards.
“The pie we have entered this year is a minted mince lamb. It’s probably our customer’s favourite pie, between that and beef shin steak & ale they’re two our biggest sellers and we just think it’s really good,” he explains.
“So the Roebuck Tavern have a limited order going to them tomorrow, so they will be cooking them over the next week or so. You can order them hot or you can order them from us and we can deliver them.”
“Pies are such a firm favourite of the country”, he says as he extols how much variety that is possible from such a humble staple dish.
“Chicken tikka and beef curry pies are all popular, but it’s great because you’re merging influences from different ethnic backgrounds into a British staple, which I think is great.”
Next week marks the beginning of British Pie Week, and Windsor’s Bakery is set to find out soon if it is successful in its quest for national recognition.
I asked Jack for any final words on this year’s submission from the household bakery, and his reply:
“I’d back it against anyone, flavour-wise… I think it’s up there.”
Good luck I say… their pies are definitely ‘up there’.
You can try out Windsor’s Bakery’s British Pie Awards entrant, the Minted Mince Lamb pie at the Roebuck Tavern in Sheffield city centre from the beginning of next week.
If you’d like to follow Windsor’s Bakery, you can go to either their Instagram or their Facebook page.
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/windsorsbakery/