Dozens of venues were put forward as brunch lovers shared their favourites, debating everything from drink flow and value for money to atmosphere and entertainment.
Some spots quickly emerged as front-runners, whilst others sparked more mixed reactions.
After counting each mention, the results revealed an incredibly tight race at the top.
There was no outright winner - with two venues finishing in joint first place after the final tally.
It was just as competitive further down the rankings, where two venues shared seventh spot, separated from others by only a handful of mentions.
From praise for “free flowing” drinks to criticism over slower service, readers made clear what matters most when it comes to bottomless brunch.
To find out where your favourite ranked take a look through the gallery below.
5. Turtle Bay
Turtle Bay came in 5th place, though it had mixed reviews with some people raving about the cocktails, and others not so impressed. Emma Louise Falkner said: "I've not found one in Sheffield to top it - my favourite." | Submit Photo: Submit
6. Panenka
Just missing out on top 3- is Panenka in 4th place. “Panenka is fab,” said Jane Darrell. Sarah Turton added: "Went to Panenka on Friday night was brilliant DJ." | Contributed Photo: Submitted
7. Mr Wilson's/Capone's
At number 3 is Mr Wilson's, a popular cocktail bar on Sheffield's West Street. Charlotte Newton said: “Mr Wilson’s is amazing, the amount of drinks we got was incredible” Downstairs is Capone's speakeasy, a luxurious hidden bar with wood panelling, plush upholstered booths and this nod to the bathtub gin made in the prohibition-era US. | Scott Merrylees Photo: Scott Merrylees
8. Kuckoo
In joint top spot, with 15% of the vote is Kuckoo. Nicola Neylon said: “Kuckoo is by far the best brunch I’ve been to.” Kuckoo offers unlimited pizza and cocktails for £40pp. | Kuckoo