Dough Truck Pizza in Sheffield has an exemplary 5.0 star rating from 130 reviews. Lizzie B said: “Friendly service and a great menu to choose from. We were served quickly and efficiently but didn’t feel rushed at all. As a family of four it’s difficult to find somewhere that ticks everyone’s boxes but dough truck did just that. The pizzas and tiramisu were some of the best we’ve ever had! Would definitely recommend an will return soon."placeholder image
Dough Truck Pizza in Sheffield has an exemplary 5.0 star rating from 130 reviews. Lizzie B said: “Friendly service and a great menu to choose from. We were served quickly and efficiently but didn’t feel rushed at all. As a family of four it’s difficult to find somewhere that ticks everyone’s boxes but dough truck did just that. The pizzas and tiramisu were some of the best we’ve ever had! Would definitely recommend an will return soon." | Tripadvisor

The best 20 places to get pizza in Sheffield ranked - according to TripAdvisor reviews

Kurtis Leyland
By Kurtis Leyland

Sports and Trends Writer

Published 10th May 2026, 05:00 GMT
Updated 10th May 2026, 05:01 GMT

Here are some of the best pizzerias in Sheffield and why customers rave about them

If it’s a good pizza you are after then you’re certainly spoilt for choice when it comes to places to dine out in Sheffield.

Whether you're a student out with friends, a family enjoying a meal out or perhaps looking for something more romantic we have you covered, with some excellent suggestions of places to enjoy the finest pizza, based on reviews on Trustpilot.

Overall, the website estimates that Sheffield has 161 places serving pizza throughout the city - and we’ve narrowed it down to the top 20 based on customer feedback.

Vito's boasts a rating of 4.7 on Trip Advisor and is hugely popular with locals. Jennie B commented: "Another wonderful evening at Vitos. We had so many varied dishes between us all. The flavours are uniquely Italian, full of flavour and Italian expertise every mouthful a delight. Thank you so much Vito and your staff for making our Christmas celebration a brilliant experience."

9. Vito's Italian Restaurant - 284 South Road Walkley, Sheffield S6 3TE England

Vito's boasts a rating of 4.7 on Trip Advisor and is hugely popular with locals. Jennie B commented: "Another wonderful evening at Vitos. We had so many varied dishes between us all. The flavours are uniquely Italian, full of flavour and Italian expertise every mouthful a delight. Thank you so much Vito and your staff for making our Christmas celebration a brilliant experience." | Google Maps

Photo Sales
This popular Crookes eatery has been a staple of the area for a long while. It has a rating of 4.7 on Trip Advisor. Annette H commented: "We visited San Lorenzo on 31 Jan 2026 for my sons birthday. We were greeted so specially on our arrival and had undivided attention for all eight throughout our visit. The atmosphere is happy pleasant and clean. Our food was superb. Absolutely first class Italian menu and food. What a wonderful Italian restaurant honestly the best in Sheffield."

10. San Lorenzo: 190-192, Northfield Rd, Crookes, Sheffield, S10 1QU

This popular Crookes eatery has been a staple of the area for a long while. It has a rating of 4.7 on Trip Advisor. Annette H commented: "We visited San Lorenzo on 31 Jan 2026 for my sons birthday. We were greeted so specially on our arrival and had undivided attention for all eight throughout our visit. The atmosphere is happy pleasant and clean. Our food was superb. Absolutely first class Italian menu and food. What a wonderful Italian restaurant honestly the best in Sheffield." | Google

Photo Sales
Leo Italian express boasts an impressive 4.7 stars on Trip Advisor. JKC praised it's affordability: "I love this place. A reduced choice menu of pizza and a pint for £12.99, wow, it’s cheaper than our local takeaway and so much nicer to be sat and served in a restaurant than at home.Pizza’s are delicious, freshly prepared and served quickly. The waiter is very obliging."

11. Leo Italian Express - 391 South Road, Sheffield S6 3TD England

Leo Italian express boasts an impressive 4.7 stars on Trip Advisor. JKC praised it's affordability: "I love this place. A reduced choice menu of pizza and a pint for £12.99, wow, it’s cheaper than our local takeaway and so much nicer to be sat and served in a restaurant than at home.Pizza’s are delicious, freshly prepared and served quickly. The waiter is very obliging." | Google Maps

Photo Sales
Ferdinandos Italian restaurant has a 4.6 rating on Trip Advisor. David P said: "Enjoyed a lovely evening with a couple of friends, the food was beautiful, we had house wine which was excellent and the service was exceptional. If you want Italian, definitely recommend this family run place."

12. Ferdinandos Italian restaurant - 329 Meadow Head, Sheffield S8 7UP England

Ferdinandos Italian restaurant has a 4.6 rating on Trip Advisor. David P said: "Enjoyed a lovely evening with a couple of friends, the food was beautiful, we had house wine which was excellent and the service was exceptional. If you want Italian, definitely recommend this family run place." | Google Maps

Photo Sales
Previous
3 / 5
Next Page
Related topics:FamilySheffieldReviewsTripAdvisorFood
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice