Readers pledge undying loyalty to 'dirty' Grindleford Station cafe hit with zero-star rating
A damning hygiene rating has triggered an avalanche of support for a traditional Peak District venue
Hundreds of readers have pledged undying loyalty to a Peak District cafe slammed with a zero-star hygiene rating.
Inspectors were left “concerned” by Grindleford Station Cafe which failed a microbiological sample test and had a history of food safety issues.
A report reveals food handlers “did not have a general understanding of food hygiene.”


And surfaces, equipment, microwaves, fridges, freezers, walls, floors and ceilings were found to be dirty.
The floor was dirty at the time of inspection, with uncooked chips stored on a tray “very close to a muddy area.”
But instead of repelling people, on The Star’s Facebook page there was a clean sweep of support.
Deborah Egan was among many who just didn’t care what the Food Standards Agency found.
She said: “Love this caf - it’s a Northern institution - dont care about mud!”
Joanne Simmonds agreed: “Granted it’s a bit of a greasy spoon, but portions are generous and cheap. Best place to eat in the Peak.”
Steve Ferris was happy to forgive.
He said: “I'm just guessing but if the Health and Safety come round to yours, or mine, there would be a similar out come.”
Steve Willey was blunt: “Lower the star, better the taste.”
Many chose humour to make their point, along the lines of “it didn’t kill me.”
John Gregory said: “Was there there yesterday, for breakfast…. Was very nice and yes, I’m still alive and kicking.”
Richard Johnson said what many were thinking: “Don’t potatoes live in mud?”
Dan Fowler had an answer: “Just gives it more of an earthy taste.”
There was even support from another eaterie.
The Barley Mow at Bonsall, mear Matlock, said: “It's great. Full of charm and character, it’s like stepping back in time, in a good way. This public shaming thing is very low.”
The cafe, next to a station on the line to Sheffield, has been the end point of hikes for years.
As such, it is seen as an essential part of a big day out.
Claire Mohamed said: “After spending several hours tramping through mud in the Peak I don’t care if the floor is a bit mucky so long as the foods nice and cutlery is clean.”
Allan Fenwick: “Best chip butties washed down with a pint mug of tea, a proper hikers’ cafe.”
Amy Snow was convinced: “Not one walker/hiker will give a damn about the ratings.
“So long as the chip butties are filled to the brim, as are the mugs of tea and coffee, and there's a spot to sit and rest.
“Long live Grindleford Cafe and all its mud.”
The cafe is also famous - beloved even - for its grumpy rules and instructions on notes pinned around the premises.
David Dean said: “It's the cafe of ‘don’ts’.
“There are signs everywhere telling you don't do this, don't do that and don't do the other.
“It's worth a visit just to read the signs, mind you I'm sure that there is one telling you not to do that also.”
Rachel Armstrong quoted one: “This is a serving hatch not a viewing gallery!"
Ryszard Szumski quoted another: “If you want to be a fireguard, join the fire service.”
David Reaney was sardonic: “Spend more money on signs telling you what to do than on cleaning equipment.”
Sarah Garrett had another: “Any changes to the menu will be charged for.” “Full English no beans please," to which the response was: "That’s a pound extra love.”
