Readers pledge undying loyalty to 'dirty' Grindleford Station cafe hit with zero-star rating

A damning hygiene rating has triggered an avalanche of support for a traditional Peak District venue

Hundreds of readers have pledged undying loyalty to a Peak District cafe slammed with a zero-star hygiene rating.

Inspectors were left “concerned” by Grindleford Station Cafe which failed a microbiological sample test and had a history of food safety issues.

A report reveals food handlers “did not have a general understanding of food hygiene.”

Grindleford Station Cafeplaceholder image
Grindleford Station Cafe | Google

And surfaces, equipment, microwaves, fridges, freezers, walls, floors and ceilings were found to be dirty.

The floor was dirty at the time of inspection, with uncooked chips stored on a tray “very close to a muddy area.”

But instead of repelling people, on The Star’s Facebook page there was a clean sweep of support.

Deborah Egan was among many who just didn’t care what the Food Standards Agency found.

She said: “Love this caf - it’s a Northern institution - dont care about mud!”

Joanne Simmonds agreed: “Granted it’s a bit of a greasy spoon, but portions are generous and cheap. Best place to eat in the Peak.”

Steve Ferris was happy to forgive.

He said: “I'm just guessing but if the Health and Safety come round to yours, or mine, there would be a similar out come.”

Steve Willey was blunt: “Lower the star, better the taste.”

Many chose humour to make their point, along the lines of “it didn’t kill me.”

John Gregory said: “Was there there yesterday, for breakfast…. Was very nice and yes, I’m still alive and kicking.”

Richard Johnson said what many were thinking: “Don’t potatoes live in mud?”

Dan Fowler had an answer: “Just gives it more of an earthy taste.”

There was even support from another eaterie.

The Barley Mow at Bonsall, mear Matlock, said: “It's great. Full of charm and character, it’s like stepping back in time, in a good way. This public shaming thing is very low.”

The cafe, next to a station on the line to Sheffield, has been the end point of hikes for years.

As such, it is seen as an essential part of a big day out.

Claire Mohamed said: “After spending several hours tramping through mud in the Peak I don’t care if the floor is a bit mucky so long as the foods nice and cutlery is clean.”

Allan Fenwick: “Best chip butties washed down with a pint mug of tea, a proper hikers’ cafe.”

Amy Snow was convinced: “Not one walker/hiker will give a damn about the ratings.

“So long as the chip butties are filled to the brim, as are the mugs of tea and coffee, and there's a spot to sit and rest.

“Long live Grindleford Cafe and all its mud.”

The cafe is also famous - beloved even - for its grumpy rules and instructions on notes pinned around the premises.

David Dean said: “It's the cafe of ‘don’ts’.

“There are signs everywhere telling you don't do this, don't do that and don't do the other.

“It's worth a visit just to read the signs, mind you I'm sure that there is one telling you not to do that also.”

Rachel Armstrong quoted one: “This is a serving hatch not a viewing gallery!"

Ryszard Szumski quoted another: “If you want to be a fireguard, join the fire service.”

David Reaney was sardonic: “Spend more money on signs telling you what to do than on cleaning equipment.”

Sarah Garrett had another: “Any changes to the menu will be charged for.” “Full English no beans please," to which the response was: "That’s a pound extra love.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice