Four Sheffield pubs including ‘best double act in the country’ feature in new book

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission on items purchased through this article, but that does not affect our editorial judgement.

For more than 40 years Mike Critchley has been on a journey where has recorded and graded each pub that he’s visited

Four Sheffield alehouses have made it into a new book, highlighting some of the country's most interesting, historic and quirky pubs.

Happy Hours – A Great British Pub Diary is a record of author Mike Critchley’s 42-year journey through character-packed inns ranging from spit-and-sawdust boozers to majestic Victorian drinking palaces.

The book is designed to take you through years of experiences highlighting both the best times - and a few low points of Mike’s journey which has seen him visit around 2,000 boozers.

Four Sheffield alehouses have made it into a new book.placeholder image
Four Sheffield alehouses have made it into a new book. | Mike Critchley

Mike has delved into the finer details of 175 pubs in total, including 27 from Yorkshire, with four of those notably coming from the Steel City.

These are two-time National CAMRA Pub of the Year Kelham Island Tavern along with Fat Cat, Gardeners Rest and Rutland Arms. A quartet which are often rated highly by our readers as well.

The Fat Cat and Kelham Island Tavern have been described as one of the best pub double acts in the country.placeholder image
The Fat Cat and Kelham Island Tavern have been described as one of the best pub double acts in the country. | Mike Critchley

Commenting on his selections, Mike explains: “Sheffield has been one of my favourite drinking cities since re-discovering it in 2015 and it helps that most of those pubs are all in good walking distance.

“The Fat Cat and Kelham Island are arguably the best pub double act in the country and I have spent many a happy hour over there with a pint or two of Pale Rider.

“I loved the Gardeners Rest – and especially that outside drinking area that the term ‘beer garden’ does not do justice.”

However, only one pub could be Mike’s favourite.

“My current favourite – in a high-quality field – is the Rutland Arms,” he said.

Mike Critchley has named the Rutland Arms as his favourite boozer in the Steel City.placeholder image
Mike Critchley has named the Rutland Arms as his favourite boozer in the Steel City. | Mike Critchley

“It is not simply the great choice of beer or those legendary ‘Rutty Butties’, but I love the quirks, eccentricities and the rebelliousness of the place. It is unique.”

Favourites aside, Mike also decided to touch on some of the drinking dens he likes to visit that didn’t get a mention in his book.

He adds: “Sheffield has so many excellent pubs and bars and the Sheffield Tap is always the great start and finish to any visit to the city.

“Of the city's newer bars I have been very impressed by Old Shoe – an excellent choice of beer and a really pleasant and welcoming vibe among staff and customers alike.

“Drinkers are spoilt for choice in the city – and there cannot be many better patches in the country than the cluster of excellent pubs in Kelham Island district; Crow Inn, Harlequin, Shakespeare’s and the Wellington.”

Mike weaves in many personal anecdotes and social history as the book charts significant changes to the way people drink and the world about us.

He adds that the challenges surrounding local pubs at the moment we’re one of the things that inspired him to write this book.

“I had to write this book,” Mike said.

“At a time when we are losing pubs hand over fist due to a multitude of reasons, this book is a reminder of the importance of these wonderful institutions and community hubs, and the role they play in society,” he said.

Priced at £14.99, the book is now on sale and can be ordered from Scratching Shed Publishing Ltd or Amazon.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice