El Toro Sheffield: A great value Broomhill tapas experience

It was throwing it down outside, and El Toro’s blooming red sign and bright windows really helped it stand out.

Actually, getting inside, the restaurant as a whole has a warm and soft-edged feeling to it that was nice and inviting, very cosy and earthy. Its menu is made out on blackboards on the walls and it seems to be exclusively rustic hardback or wicker chairs. If only it was sunnier, I’m sure the whole look comes together when the sun is beaming outside.

It was a rainy Wednesday night though…and unfortunately, it was empty when we nipped in at 6.30pm, and stayed that way while we were there. I only say it because some bustle could have lent some ambience to the visit we didn’t get to see at the time, but the waitress was very welcoming. And, another reason we picked out El Toro was they still had half an hour on their early bird special - three tapas and a drink for £15.95.

The early bird menu is all classics. Three juicy meatballs in red sauce, as good as I’ve had in England. They’ve got some great garlic mushrooms (not the crispy kind, which is what I was hoping for, but they’re still good) and the chicken wings deserve eating to the bone.

El Toro Sheffield, in Newbould Lane, Broomhill, is a cozy and great value tapas experience for the city.placeholder image
El Toro Sheffield, in Newbould Lane, Broomhill, is a cozy and great value tapas experience for the city.

My mate didn’t like the lentils and chorizo for “filling him up too quick”, he told me as I ate the rest of the dish with a spoon, not seeing his point.

I also went for an additional choice I picked off the board to go with the early bird options, which was garlic prawns, because of course, and I combo-ed the bread from the tortilla espanolas to mop up the oil.

The surprise runaway winner for both of us was El Toro’s goat cheese and beetroot salad - just sweet and earthy and sharp and great.

With the patatas alioli/bravas, these were a bit like (in a very good way) odds and ends from the chip shop...and we finished them all.

We picked a gloomy night to go to El Toro.placeholder image
We picked a gloomy night to go to El Toro.

For £42 between two people I couldn’t be happier, and another good spot in Broomhill.

El Toro's early bird special is three dishes and a drink for £15.95. Get more people in to make the most of it.placeholder image
El Toro's early bird special is three dishes and a drink for £15.95. Get more people in to make the most of it.
The meatballs are good but the winner was the goat cheese salad.placeholder image
The meatballs are good but the winner was the goat cheese salad.
Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice