Costa announces closure of popular Sheffield city centre cafe as giant new site opens

It is the second chain coffee shop in the city centre to announce closure

A Costa in Sheffield is closing to make way for a huge new unit on a premium street.

Costa in Orchard Square is closing as its new Fargate cafe opens in June.

The chain has taken the former HSBC bank premises, at 46–63 Fargate.

Costa in Orchard Square is closing.placeholder image
Costa in Orchard Square is closing. | Google

Staff are being transferred and the business is hiring, it says.

A Costa Coffee spokesperson said they had “no plans” to close the nearby Pinstone Street store.

They added: “We’re excited to be opening our new Costa Coffee store at Carmel House, 46–63 Fargate, Sheffield, in June.

“Our existing Orchard Square store will close, with all team members transferring to the new, larger Fargate location. We’ll also be recruiting additional baristas to support the opening.”

A licensing application states it wants to have 10 outside tables.

Costa is set to open in the old HSBC on Fargate in June.placeholder image
Costa is set to open in the old HSBC on Fargate in June. | IM

Property agent Paul Lancaster said they already had a tenant lined up to take the Orchard Square unit.

He added: “Footfall in Orchard Square is going up year-on-year. Waterstones and TK Maxx are trading well.”

The closure comes after Starbucks last week closed its cafe on Fargate after 18 years.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice