In Sheffield, we have almost two dozen restaurants that have an incredible five-out-of-five rating on TripAdvisor - and they cover a wide range of cuisines. From fine-dining to sushi, there’s plenty to choose from in our city.
If you’re not sure where to go for your next meal out, or you’re looking for some new inspiration, just scroll down to see all the 23 ‘best’ restaurants and cafes in Sheffield. These restaurants have a minimum of 150 reviews, and are listed in ascending order of number of reviews.
If you’re thinking about spending a full day out in our wonderful city, but you’re not sure what else to do after eating, then click here to find the top-rated things to do in Sheffield. TripAdvisor users have been busy sharing their favourite activities, including tours and attractions.
Without further ado, here are the crème de la crème of restaurants in Sheffield, according to TripAdvisor.

17. Kia's Pastaria
Kia's Pastaria, located at 759-761 Abbeydale Road, in Nether Edge, is described as an 'unassuming, compact eatery', that serves Italian dishes. On Tripadvisor it has 452 top-scoring reviews, with one customer stating: "An excellent evening out from start to finish. Reassuringly short menu with a small specials board so nothing direct from the freezer into the microwave. Very happy with the time our meal took to arrive which meant that it been freshly prepared. Excellent food and delicious home made bread." | Google

18. 400 D C
400 D C is an Indian restaurant on Castle Square, in Sheffield City Centre. It has previously been awarded Travellers' Choice 2023, and has 499 five-star reviews on Tripadvisor. One customer said it serves 'authentic' Indian food. They added: "The buffet of starters has left me wanting to sample the rest of the restaurant menu. Think it’s the best I’ve tasted." | Tripadvisor
19. The Rhubarb Shed
The Rhubarb Shed, at Manor Lodge, is a cafe that has been awarded the Travellers' Choice 2023. It serves breakfast, brunch, and afternoon tea, and it's very popular, with 513 stellar reviews - so book in advance! One customer said: "Heard good things about the Rhubarb Shed and wasn’t disappointed. Went in a large family group for breakfast after previously booking a table. Nice rural type setting with an old feel to it. Excellent choice of food for everyone to choose from including vegetarian and gluten free." | National World

20. Grazie
Grazie is a very popular restaurant in Sheffield, and re-opened at its current venue on Leopold Street in November 2022. It is the fourth most highly-rated restaurant in the city on TripAdvisor, with 639 five-star reviews. One customer said: "We visited Grazie for lunch with friends. The food was excellent - authentic Italian cuisine, cooked and presented with care. The atmosphere was relaxed, staff were friendly and service was excellent. If we lived nearby we would definitely be regular visitors!" | National World Photo: Dean Atkins


