20 of the best Italian restaurants in Sheffield according to TripAdvisor reviews

Don’t fancy cooking tonight?

Friday, 1st November 2019, 12:25 pm
Updated Friday, 1st November 2019, 1:31 pm
Best Italian restaurants in Sheffield
Best Italian restaurants in Sheffield

Why not try one of these top-rated Sheffield Italian restaurants for a hot pizza or hearty bowl of pasta – as reviewed by TripAdvisor users.

Topping the list on TripAdvisor is Napoli Centro, which has a number of five star reviews. One dinner commented that here you can expect: The true taste of Naples here in Yorkshire.
The food was delicious (really delicious) and the service excellent, reads one review of Olive Restaurant, which comes in at second place for Italian restaurants in Sheffield.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

One recent diner came to Dos Amigos mistakenly after booking in at the restaurant nextdoor, but called the incident: the best mistake we ever made. They added that the food was fantastic.
The food was very homey and filling without being massive portions, reads one review of Piccolos. The diner especially recommended the bruschetta.
In fifth place is Bragazzis, which one diner claims to have been coming to every week for around 6 years, enjoying the coffee as well as the other Italian delicacies on offer.
Really enjoyed the food. Staff were very friendly. Lovely authentic Italian meal - reads one five-star review of Vito’s.
Kias Pastaria, also on Abbeydale Road, is also a popular Italian spot with locals and tourists. One reviewer wrote: We adore this restaurant. The best Italian food for miles around.
Typical Italian with a modern twist is what one diner found at Marco at Milano. They also called the staff very attentive and efficient.
For great Italian food on Norfolk Row, head to VeroGusto. One recent diner wrote the following review of it: Three wonderful courses - slow cooked beef ragu was to die for. As ever the service was great.
First time in Kito's and not the last , the homemade bread is lovely , we had some stuffed chicken from the special board and some tuna both really nice, reads one glowing review of Kito’s.
Pizza is the most frequently mentioned food in reviews of prove, with one reviewer writing: Honestly we could have been in Italy it was all so delicious. Friendly staff. A great find and good value.
Stupendo!! Best Italian in Sheffield...fab home cooked food. Good service and always a warm welcome, reads one recent review of Rossi’s.
A few reviews of Caffe Piazza praised the service as well as the food, with one guest writing: the chef went above and beyond to make me my specified meal, even though the restaurant was very busy.
Lovely Evening, Beautiful Food, Quality Service! - reads one recent five-star review of Maranell’s, another Italian on the popular Ecclesall Road.
The rather strangely-named Bloo 88 also gets glowing reviews on TripAdvisor, with one reviewer writing: Pizzas were the best I have tasted in a long long time. I forget the names but all tasted so fresh.
The food was excellent and atmosphere, though quiet, was lovely. The starter of mussels in the basket made from bread was superb - reads one five-star review of Casanova.
One large group who ate at Ponti’s recently wrote on TripAdvisor: 6 of us all got something different and we’re very pleased with the food delivered!
We recently visited this restaurant for a family birthday party. Everyone enjoyed their meal, which is asking a lot as their tastes are very varied, reads one recent five-star review of Sette Colli.
One recent review of La Gondola reads: Myself and my partner had pizza to share, and god it was lovely, fresh and tasty.
Just making it into the top 20 for Italian restaurants in Sheffield is San Lorenzo. One reviewer said: The food is always well presented, hot and tasty. The staff are friendly and the host Veri is extremely friendly