Nazi bombs, secret hiding places and an 80-year riddle finally solved - the incredible story of how valuable stained glass lost from a Sheffield church was finally found decades later

It sounds like a storyline straight out of an Indiana Jones movie - but a decades long mystery involving Nazi bombs, secret cavernous hiding places and valuable missing stained glass from a city church can finally be unravelled today.

Wednesday, 29th July 2020, 1:56 pm

As the country became engulfed in the conflict of the Second World War a decision was taken to take down the stained glass windows at St Mary's Church in Bramall Lane and hide them underground to protect them from Nazi bombs.

But just a year later the church was damaged in the Sheffield Blitz and the records detailing the secret hiding place containing the valuable glass became lost.

However, the glass has now been found and sold at auction last year with the windows now with their new owner in Buckinghamshire.

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

One of the missing 13 stained glass panels from St Mary's Church bought by Colin Mantripp at auction in Buckinghamshire

Colin Mantripp, who owns a wood carving studio, bought what he thought was a box of fragments of stained glass which he could use in his bespoke designs.

He said: "I didn't go to the auction and just put a bid in. I think I only put in £300 and so I was completely surprised when it wasn't a small box of glass I went to pick up but an 8 foot by 3 foot wooden box full of 13 beautiful stained glass panels."Colin said he did not know where the seller got the glass from but noticed the outside of the box had St Mary's scrawled on the side.

After some research on the internet he found the story of St Mary's missing glass and realised he had the missing windows.

He said: "Although I bought them I wanted to let the church know I had them and made contact with them and offered to gift all the windows back to St Mary's if they were in a position to put them back in the church where they belong."

St mary's church stained glass mystery. Rev Claire Dawson

The church has kindly declined the offer and Reverend Claire Dawson said: "The windows are an important part of the church's history which dates back to 1830 and as nice as it would be to see them so much has changed for the church for the better that it wouldn't be practical to have them back."

In 1939, the great 20-by-12-foot neo-Gothic east window which shone down over the altar of St Mary’s, was removed to avoid bomb damage, and stored with other stained glass from the church hundreds of feet below ground.

As the location had been lost rumours vary as to the where the glass was hidden with some saying it was buried in a South Yorkshire coalfield, others claimed it was down a Peak District cavern while some believed the glass was buried in a North Wales mine.

After the church was devastated during the Sheffield Blitz it took almost 20 years before restoration work could begin and with the windows lost the church had clear glass instead.

The stained glass was taken down from the church in 1939 to protect it when the country was on the brink of war with Germany.

The restoration in the 1950s in­volved a then-revolutionary scheme, in which its huge nave, originally designed for 2000 worshippers, was cut in two to create a community centre and a smaller church. It was successful, and in the 1990s it under­went a £3-million modernisation.

Today, the church, which is next to Sheffield United’s football ground, has a congregation of about 60. The community centre has been con­verted into a conference venue, where up to 1000 people attend meetings each week.

Rev Dawson said: "We are so much more than we were in 1939 we wouldn't be able to display them anymore as windows as we have a beautiful new window which was installed above the altar and is a celebration of the journey from the church's beginning to the present day."

In 2009 the glass was replaced and by a new £80,000 a modern abstract design window which was funded by the Arts Council and created by Helen Whittaker.

The glass was buried underground but after a landmine destroyed the church the location was then lost.

Colin added: "I understand why the church can't have them back as it has evolved and changed over time but people are still going to the church so the building has a continued purpose which is great. I'd hate to see it fall to ruin if it wasn't being used at all.

"One of the windows is very broken so it's perfect for my line of work but I'm not sure what to do with all the other windows. As they were commissioned for a church it would be nice to try and get them back into a church but I don’t know how that would work."

A message from the Editor:

Thank you for reading this story. The dramatic events of 2020 are having a major impact on our advertisers and thus our revenues.

The Star is more reliant than ever on you taking out a digital subscription to support our journalism. You can subscribe here for unlimited access to Sheffield news and information online.

Every subscription helps us continue providing trusted, local journalism and campaign on your behalf for our city.

Colin bought a box of stained glass fragments from an auction last year however when it turned up it was a big box full of glass panels

Thank you

Nancy Fielder, editor

The box bought by Colin had St Mary's on the side of it and it was only after some research he realised he had the missing church windows
Despite being buried underground for decades the glass in in remarkably good condition
Colin approached the church but since a new window was commissioned in 2009 a decision was made to not have the glass back
Sadly Colin doesn't know how the missing glass ended up at auction 80 years later and that will remain a mystery
Damage during the Sheffield Blitz.