Decision to reduce free IVF cycles on NHS in South Yorkshire branded 'shocking'

The decision by South Yorkshire health bosses to reduce the number of IVF cycles available on the NHS is “shocking”, councillors have said.

Bosses at the South Yorkshire Integrated Care Board (ICB) described the move as a “difficult decision”, but interim chief executive Chris Edwards said it was important to deliver the “best value for money” in a “difficult financial climate”.

The ICB has cut the number of NHS provided IVF cycles in South Yorkshire from two cycles to one, despite pressure from local leaders not to do so.

In vitro fertilisation (IVF) is a fertility treatment which led to the birth of over 20,000 babies in 2023 or roughly one in every classroom, according to data from the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA).

Cllr Gemma Cobby put forward a motion in Doncaster against the ICB's proposals to cut IVF cycles in South Yorkshire to one.placeholder image
Cllr Gemma Cobby put forward a motion in Doncaster against the ICB's proposals to cut IVF cycles in South Yorkshire to one. | Doncaster Council

Councillor Gemma Cobby, who represents town ward on the City of Doncaster Council, said: “I’m devastated… I don’t know what they are getting out of this.

“The devastation of couples, women, individuals, will be more significant and they won’t realise that for a couple of years… It’s just really heartbreaking.”

Cobby’s sentiment was echoed by Finningley ward Conservative councillor Jane Cox.

Councillor Jane Cox said she was “stunned” by the decision.placeholder image
Councillor Jane Cox said she was “stunned” by the decision. | City of Doncaster Council

“One round of IVF is shocking. I’m actually quite stunned,” Cllr Cox said.

“It’s dreadfully unfair as few women get pregnant from their first cycle,” she added.

The IVF success rate on a first cycle varies by the age of the patient with those under 35 having the best chance, however, research suggests this is still under 50 per cent.

Cllr Cobby said she believed the consultation the ICB undertook was a waste of money.

“It just makes no sense why they continued with it and why they put out the consultation if they were going to do it anyway,” she said.

Two South Yorkshire councils – Doncaster and Sheffield – and some local MPs joined dozens of consultation respondents in objecting to the move.

Sheffield City Council has also publicly announced opposition to the IVF cycle cut.placeholder image
Sheffield City Council has also publicly announced opposition to the IVF cycle cut. | Iconic Media Group

At a meeting of Doncaster’s full council in September 2025, Cllr Cobby tabled a motion declaring the council’s opposition to the ICB’s decision, which was still in consultation at the time.

It received tremendous cross-party support, with 50 of the 51 councillors in attendance voting to support it, as well as the Mayor of Doncaster Ros Jones.

Cllr Nicola Brown, a Reform UK councillor for Adwick & Carcroft ward, told the meeting: “Being a mother and grandmother is the best gift in the world and I fully support this motion in the hopes it helps someone.”

Nicola Brown (pictured) spoke passionately in support of Cllr Cobby’s motion in Doncaster.placeholder image
Nicola Brown (pictured) spoke passionately in support of Cllr Cobby’s motion in Doncaster. | Doncaster Council

In a statement following the ICB decision, Mr Edwards said: “The ICB Board has made the difficult decision to move from offering two funded IVF cycles to one, which brings our policy in line with the majority of ICBs in England.

“We recognise how important IVF services are for those affected, and this decision has not been taken lightly by the board.

“IVF is just one of the areas identified for review by the ICB. We are examining a range of services in line with our organisational priorities, the needs of our citizens, clinical outcomes, cost effectiveness and the delivery of essential services.

“This has been an extremely tough choice, but it must be considered in the wider context of improving health outcomes for our whole population and ensuring fair access to services for everyone across South Yorkshire.

“We remain committed to offering fertility treatment for our population and through our new policy will continue to support hundreds of people in South Yorkshire every year.”

The South Yorkshire ICB said the change would only apply to new referrals. Existing IVF patients would continue on their current plans.

It added that where there is evidence of exceptional circumstances an individual funding request could be put forward by a patient’s clinician.

Cllr Cobby has previously highlighted how the decision will compound issues facing women’s health services, which she said were “often overlooked” and it can “take a long time for lots of women’s issues to be taken seriously”.

Speaking with the Local Democracy Reporting Service after the ICB decision, she pointed to endometriosis – a condition which can cause women difficulty getting pregnant.

“It takes up to eight years for women to be diagnosed with that,” she said. “There’s just not enough research on a lot of women’s health issues.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice