First secondary school in Sheffield rated under new Ofsted rules receives lacklustre score

Inspectors remain lukewarm towards one of Sheffield’s largest secondary schools after years of trying to get back in Ofsted’s good books.

Westfield School, in Eckington Road, was dealt a ‘requires improvement’ rating by the watchdog in 2013 and even dipped into ‘inadequate’ before it was taken over by Chorus Education Trust in 2018.

Celebrating at Westfield School on GCSE Results Day 2023.placeholder image
Celebrating at Westfield School on GCSE Results Day 2023. | Westfield School

Now, Westfield School has been handed another lacklustre write up in its latest Ofsted inspection, meaning it has not risen to a grade of ‘Good’ in 13 years.

Headteacher Gaynor Jones said: “It’s been a year and a half since I joined Westfield School as headteacher and I’m proud of the improvements we’ve made for our pupils and our school community. We know that we are still on a journey of improvement, and we understand where our current strengths and weaknesses are.

“We are working hard to improve the consistency of our teaching and assessments, and to improve attendance.

“We look forward to inviting Ofsted back in the near future to see the full impact of the plans we already have in place to ensure Westfield School becomes the successful, respectful, safe and happy place it can be.”

Westfield School, in Sheffield, has sadly been handed another lacklustre Ofsted report after 13 years of trying to get back in the watchdog's good books.placeholder image
Westfield School, in Sheffield, has sadly been handed another lacklustre Ofsted report after 13 years of trying to get back in the watchdog's good books. | Victoria Greensmith Photography

Westfield School is the first secondary in Sheffield to have its rating published after being inspected under Ofsted’s new ‘report card’ guidelines.

The new report scores Westfield as “needing attention” in all areas of school life and criticised weaknesses in teaching, attendance and SEND provision.

However, inspectors noted the school is “calmer” and that pupils “appreciate it is improving,” with many systems to improve learning only recently put in place.

The report reads: “Pupils do not secure the knowledge they need in some subjects and year groups... The gap between disadvantaged pupils and their peers has widened.

“Pupils appreciate that this school is improving and feel that staff want the best for them.

“They build positive relationships with staff, who know them well. Most pupils behave well and respond to the ‘Westfield Way’ expectations.

“Leaders have created a calmer, caring and more orderly environment. Pupils usually behave well in lessons and around the site.

“Leaders do not tolerate bullying, discrimination or harassment and pupils are confident that staff will take action if they report these.

“However, some pupils have not developed the learning behaviours needed to help them succeed.

“Too many pupils miss school too often. This affects how well they achieve and how fully they can take part in school life.

“Leaders are working to address this, but more improvement is needed so that all pupils can realise their full potential and achieve well.”

It compares to the school’s last report in 2023, when conduct in the corridors was called ”boisterous” and leaders did not have a grasp of their own strengths and weaknesses, both of which were complimented in the latest write up.

Former head of Westfield Joe Birkirk left in late 2024.

Ofsted’s new ‘report card’ system no longer gives schools one-word summaries like ‘Good’ or ‘Inadequate’, but grades different areas as either ‘Exceptional’, ‘Strong standard’. ‘Expected standard’, ‘Needs attention’, or ‘Urgent improvement’.

The system was introduced following the death of Berkshire headteacher Ruth Perry who took her own life after an Ofsted report downgraded her school from its highest rating of “outstanding” to its lowest rating, “inadequate”.

The new system hopes to be “clearer and fairer” by increasing the number of areas schools will be judged on and be more specific on what needs to improve.

However, unions are concerned teaching staff will be under pressure to produce far more evidence to impress inspectors. Critics also say the definition of “expected standard” is more demanding.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice