This week (March 1), Steel City pupils and their parents were told which of their three preferences they will be going to for the new academic year this September.
Now, the latest data shows which of Sheffield’s ‘big schools’ offering places for Y7 had to refuse the most applicants, making them the hardest to get into for 2023.
None of Sheffield’s secondary schools listed here had to turn away more children than they have seats in the classroom, in comparison to primary schools, which each year can often have up to three children vying for every seat in the classroom.
A school’s oversubscription rate is determined by how many children it had to turn away in comparison to the number of places it had to offer.
Statistically, the most oversubscribed secondary school in Sheffield was once again Mercia School, in Millhouses, which had to turn away 137 pupils while filling its 180 places. This also means Mercia has one of the smallest intakes in the city. The only school with a smaller Y7 cohort is Oasis Academy Don Valley, who will welcome 160 new students this September.
Comparatively, King Edward VII School had to turn away 107 pupils while filling its 240 places, making it the second most oversubscribed while having a larger cohort.
For the list of which schools in the city are the most oversubscribed, see our gallery below.
Not on our list below are Stocksbridge, Birley, Ecclesfield and Bradfield schools, which it is understood are undersubscribed this year, in that they are starting this year with places still available in their classrooms.
Also not listed here are All Saints and Notre Dame Catholic schools, which the city council could not provide the data for. The Star has contacted both schools and will update the data below when it is available.
Sheffield City Council says 96 per cent of students this academic year received a place at one of their three preferred schools, and 88 percent received their first preference.

5. Handsworth Grange Community Sports College
Handsworth Grange Community Sports College slipped from ‘outstanding’ to ‘requires improvement’ in an Ofsted inspection this January. However, this year it is the fourth most oversubscribed, and turned away 75 pupils while fillings its 205 places. Photo: Google

6. Silverdale School
Silverdale School was the second most oversubscribed school in Sheffield last year, but this year had both more spaces to offer and turned away less children. It turned away 70 pupils while filling its 240 places, making it the sixth hardest school to get into. Photo: JPI

7. Oasis Academy Don Valley
Oasis Academy Don Valley was the seventh most oversubscribed, turning away 42 pupils to fill its 160 places. This also means the school had the smallest intake in the city for 2023. Photo: Marie Caley

8. High Storrs School
High Storrs School was the eighth most oversubscribed school in Sheffield for 2023, turning away 57 pupils to fill its 244 places. Photo: Alastair Ulke


