The Star has compiled and ranked the top 10 secondary schools by their ‘Attainment 8’ scores in the gallery below.
In late February, the Department for Education published the ‘Attainment 8’ scores for England’s schools.
This is a score schools get based on how well pupils have performed in up to eight qualifications, made up of a combination of English, maths, sciences, computer science, history, geography and languages, and other qualifications.
Alongside those are figures for how many pupils earned at least a Grade 5 in English and maths, as well as the number of pupils who entered 'EBacc' - shorthand for if pupils study English, maths, sciences, a language, and either history or geography
They are not the official metric the Government uses to gauge how well a school is doing - but they do give a good insight into what kind of grades pupils get at each school in Sheffield.
The list below is only for academy and maintained schools, but still includes standouts like Mercia School earning the highest grades in the city - 68.1 - and outpacing independent schools like Westbourne School and Bethany School.
Other high flyers include High Storrs, Tapton and Silverdale.
It’s another year where the traditionally accepted benchmark scores used by the DfE, known as Progress 8 scores, are only hold due to the pandemic. The class of 2025 would have been in Year 6 when the Covid-19 pandemic struck in 2020.

1. Mercia School
The secondary school with the best grades in Sheffield in 2024-2025 was, once again, Mercia School, with an Attainment 8 score of 68.1, with 100 per cent of its eligible students entering for EBacc and 95 per cent of students earning a Grade 5 or higher in English and Maths. The Outstanding rated school is one of the best performing in the country at the last round of Progress 8 scores, which have been temporarily suspended as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic. | Google

2. High Storrs School
High Storrs School scored the second best GCSE grades in Sheffield in 2024-2025, with an Attainment 8 score of 61, with 74.4 per cent of its eligible students entering for EBacc and 70.2 per cent of students earning a Grade 5 or higher in English and Maths. | National World

3. Tapton School
Tapton School had the third best GCSE grades in Sheffield in 2024-2025, with an attainment 8 score of 58, plus 49.4 per cent of its eligible students entering for EBacc and 67.7 per cent of students earning a Grade 5 or higher in English and Maths. The school was named top Comprehensive School of the Year in the North by The Sunday Times' Parent Power Guide 2025. | Tapton School

4. Silverdale School
Silverdale School had the fourth best GCSE grades in Sheffield in 2024-2025, with an Attainment 8 score of 56.7, with 47.1 per cent of its eligible students entering for EBacc and 70.1 per cent of students earning a Grade 5 or higher in English and Maths. Silverdale also recorded the second best A-Level results in the city in 2025 and rated the 7th top comprehensive school in the North in the Sunday Times Parent Power Guide. | Andrew Roe/AHPIX LTD
