As Ofsted changed regulations and are no longer publishing single-word ratings, The Telegraph has created a new secondary school league table for 2025.
Secondary schools are ranked according to 10 separate criteria, which add up to a maximum score of 40.
Using data for the 2023/24 academic year, the points are awarded as follows:
- English Baccalaureate scores (5 points)
- Attainment 8 scores (5 points)
- Progress 8 score (5 points)
- Disadvantaged pupils score (4 points)
- Comparison with local authority (4 points)
- Pupil destinations (5 points)
- Entries options (3 points)
- Oversubscribed schools (3 points)
- Class size (3 points)
- Truancy (3 points)
An accumulative score is then used to identify a rating, ranging from ‘very good’, to ‘good’, ‘fair’, ‘below average’ and ‘poor.
This data has been used to create a ranking list of the top 100 schools, with one in Sheffield taking one of the top spots.
High Storrs School was ranked third in the country, acquiring a perfect score of 40/40 in the national publication’s league table.
So we’ve gone through the rest of the data published to find how 20 secondary schools in the city faired.
Find the full list below.

5. Mercia School
Mercia was rated 'very good' on the Telegraph's league table, scoring 34/40. | Google

6. Forge Valley School
The academy on Wood Lane received a score of 27/40, giving it a 'fair' rating on the Telegraph's league table. | Google

7. All Saints' Catholic High School
The Telegraph rated All Saints' as 'fair', with a score of 26/40. | Google

8. Meadowhead School Academy Trust
This school on Dyche Lane was rated as 'fair' on the Telegraph's league table. It achieved a score of 25/40. | Google

