Sheffield Professor urges tailored approach to youth unemployment amid Milburn’s NEET report

As Alan Milburn’s report proposes billions in spending and welfare reforms to tackle young people not in education, employment or training, a Sheffield economics professor cautions against treating this diverse group as a uniform issue.

A Sheffield professor has warned that government must not treat young people as “a single, uniform problem”, as Alan Milburn long-awaited report on the issue of NEETs was published.

Alan Milburn speaking at Google offices in London, about his final report into young people not in employment, education or training (Neets).placeholder image
Alan Milburn speaking at Google offices in London, about his final report into young people not in employment, education or training (Neets). | Stefan Rousseau/Press Association

The former cabinet minister called on backbench Labour MPs to back his plan, even though welfare cuts could mean some youngsters having their benefits reduced.

The Government-commissioned report calls for billions of taxpayers’ money to be spent creating opportunities for those aged under 25 to get off benefits and into work, partly offsetting the cost by squeezing welfare payments.

Launching his report, Mr Milburn said: “Britain is at risk of losing a generation of young people, not because they lack talent, not because they lack ambition, not because they do not want to work. This is not a crisis of aspiration; it is a crisis of opportunity.”

He said “half measures will not do” because “the scale of the problem is just too big for that”.

The report calls for the Government to spend around £5.8 billion a year by 2036-37, funding a new youth opportunity service and support, including tax breaks and bonuses for firms employing young people.

The cost would be offset by £3.6 billion of annual welfare savings and £2.4 billion of extra tax revenue from people in work.

Mr Milburn said the increasing number of 16- 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training (Neet) was a “moral crisis”.

In response, Andy Dickerson, a Professor of Economics at the University of Sheffield, said: "Policymakers must avoid treating over a million young Britons as a single, uniform problem - or relying solely on labour-market fixes.

"While new proposals for an Opportunity Guarantee, expanded job subsidies, and faster mental health access are welcome steps, youth disengagement cannot be solved at age 18 alone. A recent graduate navigating an AI-driven hiring freeze faces vastly different barriers from a young carer, a care leaver, or an economically inactive teenager managing severe anxiety or neurodivergence. Blanket welfare conditionality risks penalising the most vulnerable rather than supporting them.

"Crucially, becoming NEET is predictable years before a young person enters the job market. Children who are not school-ready at age five are nearly three times more likely to become NEET at 16, with persistent school absence, unmet special educational needs, and unequal access to work experience serving as clear early-warning signals.

"True reform also means shutting off the NEET pipeline at its source - pairing labour-market opportunities with sustained investment in early years, inclusive schools, and family support.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice