Milburn review welcomed in South Yorkshire with caveat ”fiddling around the edges” won’t fix youth unemployment

Proposals to tackle youth unemployment have been welcomed, but real change will take a decade of consistent support.

Social enterprises in South Yorkshire have said they welcome new proposals to tackle youth unemployment, but have warned that real change will take a decade of consistent support rather than short-term fixes.

Alan Milburn set out a 10-year plan on Tuesday (November 17) aimed at reducing the number of 16 to 24-year-olds who are not in education, employment or training (NEET).

Milburn's report aims to reduce the number of young people currently classified as NEETs from 13 percent to 5 percent.

In Sheffield, social enterprises who help inspire young people and expose them to work opportunities, are pleased by the report’s push for early intervention for those at risk of becoming NEETs .

Skills Street in Rotherham helps inspire young people who are still in education to look at careers and gain confidence while getting ready for the world of work.

They introduce young people to the different job sectors and local employers across South Yorkshire ranging from construction and aviation to advanced manufacturing to ‘see what they could aspire to’.

John Barber, Skills Street Director said: “We get feedback from teachers saying ‘that child's never really engaged in school’.

“But if you put them in an environment where it may be a hands-on activity or something that really sparks their interest, that child will come alive and they'll engage with it.”

Skills Street in Rotherham helps inspire young people who are still in education to look at careers and gain confidence while getting ready for the world of work.placeholder image
Skills Street in Rotherham helps inspire young people who are still in education to look at careers and gain confidence while getting ready for the world of work. | Skills Street

Onboard Skatepark Sheffield gives young people a unique approach to education by combining extreme sports like skateboarding, BMX and scootering with academic development.

They offer an Alternative Provision program which tailors to young people's needs who may struggle in traditional classroom settings.

Amy Cooper, Founder and CEO of Onboard Skatepark said: “Around 80 percent of the students we have got are from single parent families that don't work.

“They know the basics, but not actually what else is out there, so we just want to be able to sort of open their eyes to opportunities.”

Amy says that the Milburn report is reassuring for them: “It shows that not one service or organisation can solve that NEET problem for one young person, it has to be a collective.

John said: “The challenge will be, how are you going to tackle this? And it can't just be fiddling around the edges. It's got to be a fundamental change to systems and structures, starting in school. It's no good waiting until they become NEET."

The report highlights both anxiety and lack of confidence as major barriers to work for those classified as NEET. At Skills Street early intervention is key in improving confidence and engagement.

Skills Street introduce young people to the different job sectors and local employers across South Yorkshire.placeholder image
Skills Street introduce young people to the different job sectors and local employers across South Yorkshire. | Skills Street

Amy said: “When a child becomes a NEET, it's a journey to get there, this isn't something that happens overnight, so what we really want to do is work around that prevention.”

The report calls for doubling the number of young people completing apprenticeships and wants schools to have a legal duty to provide work experience to prepare pupils for the workplace.

It also proposes a £3,000 grant and tax breaks to encourage firms to take on young people.

John said: “The incentives will definitely help and the proposal around cutting national insurance in some sectors.

“However, it's not just about finance. It's about the additional support and resources you've got to put into supporting one person.”

The report has also recommended giving regional mayors more control over local youth employment plans.

John said: “I think that local control will help. The mayoral authority, hopefully, will help them collectively instead of having four plans for South Yorkshire.”

Milburn's “complete system reset” to bring down the number of NEETs could take up to 10 years to see full results.

John said: “If we’re going to make a difference it’s not going to happen overnight, Milburn is right.

“I hope that whether it's this government or the next government that this is implemented and done right and they see the plan through.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice