The latest data for what Sheffield’s sixth form colleges and schools earned on A-Level Results Day 2025 have been published by the Government.
Each year, the Department for Education releases each school’s average grades and ranks them using performance points system that rates each college out of 60.
And while there were success stories, the majority of Sheffield’s A-Level offerings have slipped below the average for England.
After already earning the best GCSE grades in the city, Mercia School also now claims the best A-Level results outside of private schools, with its inaugural sixth form intake topping the list.
The average point score in England in 2025 came to 36.8, or an average grade of B-.
But 13 out of Sheffield 18 A-Level colleges scored lower than the national average.
Here are the average grades and point scores for Sheffield’s sixth form colleges and school at A-Level in 2025.
Sheffield’s special schools and private schools have not been listed in this gallery.
- RELATED: Ofsted praise 10 Sheffield schools and nurseries in latest ratings
- RELATED: Ideas for old pop museum pour in as university mulls 'options'
- RELATED: Sheffield school "delighted" as they celebrate latest Ofsted report
- RELATED: Sheffield primary school praised for "happy, safe and secure" environment by Ofsted

1. In first place, Mercia School
Fresh off of launching their Sixth Form provision in 2024, and Mercia School has now scored the best A-Level results in Sheffield outside of private education. The Carter Knowle Road secondary school now consistently scores as one of the best performing in the country for GCSE results and Progress 8 scores, and now it has the best A-Level results in its very first year, with an average grade of B+ and a score of 42.13. Curiously, the DfE graded Mercia as "below average" in its progress scores - suggesting its pupils GCSE grades were so high that their otherwise top-scoring results at A-Level were considered a step down, at least by national metrics. In any case, Mercia last week announced it has already secured five OxBridge candidates for 2026. | Google

2. Silverdale School
Silverdale School has firmly established itself in recent years as one of the top performing schools in Sheffield following a significant expansion. In 2024/25, its 312 students earned an average grade point of 40.37, giving it an average grade of B. Silverdale was also rated the 7th top comprehensive school in the North in the Sunday Times Parent Power Guide, published in December 2025. | Silverdale School

3. Tapton School
Tapton School was named top Comprehensive School of the Year in the North by The Sunday Times' Parent Power Guide 2025. In 2025, its 217 students earned an A-Level point score of 39.5, giving it an average grade of B. | Tapton School
4. High Storrs School
High Storrs School reported a record high of nine OxBridge places in 2025, along with strong A-Level results across the board. Its 218 students earned an average point score of 38.37, giving it an average A-Level grade of B. Photo: Submitted
