Mum hits out at 'no phones' Sheffield school for confiscating daughter's mobile for four weeks

“Having her phone taken off her with no alternative is so disruptive. It’s draconian.”

A mum has hit out at a Sheffield secondary school’s ‘no phones’ policy after locking up her autistic daughter’s mobile for a month.

The pupil at Astrea Academy, in Pitsmoor, reportedly forgot to surrender her phone first thing in the morning on April 16.

Astrea Academy Sheffield welcomed the incoming ban on mobile phones in England - but on mum has hit out at how her daughter’s mobile was confiscated for four weeks.placeholder image
Astrea Academy Sheffield welcomed the incoming ban on mobile phones in England - but on mum has hit out at how her daughter’s mobile was confiscated for four weeks. | Local Library

When a member of staff saw the “outline” of the phone in her pocket later that day, it was confiscated on the spot - and she was told it would stay in the school office for four weeks.

“It’s excessive and disproportionate,” the mum,who asked not to be named, told The Star.

“She’s a good kid who doesn’t get in trouble, but there was no warning or first strike.

“I don’t disagree with banning phones in schools, but you know how kids are with phones these days. They’re dependent on them.

“She uses her phone to stay in touch with me, contact her dad, make payments for buses and shops, study for her mocks.

“Having her phone taken off her with no alternative is so disruptive. It’s draconian.”

Several schools in the Astrea Academy Trust operate a no-phones policy, with a guidance page calling them “addictive”, “linked to mental health problems” and preventing “children from being children.”

“The presence of a phone will stop children getting to university,” the page reads.

“Children will not be thinking about Pythagoras when there is a phone in their pocket.”

The trust also welcomed early reports of impending ban on phones in schools in England by the Government.

The Sheffield mum said: “I don’t disagree with the ban. What I disagree with is four weeks’ confiscation with no way to just give them back to parents instead, or give a warning.

“What about children to and from school without a phone? What about the lockdowns at other schools like Fir Vale and Birley Academy where children can’t contact their parents?

“I would like them to look at their policy. I think it’s too rigid for children with SEND or make allowances for well behaved children who just forget. What lesson does it teach having your phone taken for four weeks?”

A spokesperson for Astrea Academy Trust said: “Astrea Academy Sheffield is a mobile phone-free school. This policy puts us ahead of recent Department for Education requirements that schools should be phone-free environments.

“We believe our approach, now echoed in government policy, lets children be children, shields them from the pressures of social media, protects them from online harms and helps keep their focus on their education.

“In September 2025, Astrea Academy Sheffield introduced phone pouches; parents, carers and students were kept fully informed of this prior to launching the scheme.

“Students must seal their phones and other devices safely in their pouch, keeping it locked during the school day. Staff remind them about this regularly in assemblies and as they enter the school grounds.

“Since the introduction of these pouches, we have seen a reduction in incidents involving mobile phones and in students missing lessons.

“Our behaviour policy, which we have communicated with parents, carers and students, sets out clearly that if a phone is seen or heard during the school day, it will be confiscated for a period of four weeks.”

Phone ban in all schools in England

The upset came in the same week the Government announced it would ban mobile phones in all schools in England.

An amendment to the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill will make excluding phones a legal requirement, monitored by Ofsted.

A spokesperson for the DfE said: "We have been consistently clear that mobile phones have no place in schools, and the majority already prohibit them.

"This amendment makes existing guidance statutory, giving legal force to what schools are already doing in practice.

"It builds on the steps we've already taken to strengthen enforcement, with Ofsted considering schools' mobile phone policies as part of inspection from this month.

"We will always put children's interests first, including through this Bill - which is widely recognised as the biggest piece of child safeguarding legislation in decades, with critical measures like laws to crack down on profiteering in children's social care and a new unique identifier to stop children falling through the cracks."

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice