From time to time, it’s worth taking note of which Sheffield schools are still on an improvement journey and aren’t yet in the ‘good’ books with Ofsted.
There are currently 11 primary or secondary schools in the Steel City rated as 'requires improvement' or ‘inadequate’ by the education watchdog, according to its website.
Many have been waiting for a reinspection for up to two years, which was no doubt delayed in 2023 when inspections were paused while staff underwent ‘sensitivity’ training following the death of headteacher Ruth Perry.
Ms Perry took her own life after learning her Reading-based school would be downgraded from ‘outstanding’ to ‘inadequate.’
The watchdog came under nationwide criticism, and led to urgent changes to their inspection framework. It is widely considered that inspection ratings have been less harsh since they resumed in mid-2023.
That said, many of these ratings are from after inspections resumed. In many cases, the inspection reports are not without compliments, such as how pupils at Acres Hill Community Primary are "proud of their school and happy to attend," and how Handsworth Grange Community Spots College’s students “behave well and show positive attitudes to their education.”
Both of Sheffield’s remaining ‘inadequate’ schools - Chaucer School and St Patrick’s Catholic Voluntary Academy - were rated in 2024 and are awaiting re-inspections.
But, often, the overall grade for schools is brought down by some crucial weakness or gaps in how children are taught in an otherwise adequate report, such as slip-ups in the 'quality of education' at Birley Spa Academy.
See our gallery below for all Sheffield schools currently rated ‘requires improvement’ or ‘inadequate’.

5. Aston Academy - Requires Improvement
Aston Academy, in Aughton Road, Swallownest, was rated Requires Improvement in January 2024 after inspectors found a distinct split between pupils who are "happy" and those "dissatisfied" with their time at school. While the report was not without its compliments, they wrote: "Some pupils are happy, but others are dissatisfied with their experiences at the school." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/23/136718 | National World

6. Westfield School - Requires Improvement
Westfield School, in Eckington Road, was rated 'Requires Improvement' in a report published on July 2023. Inspectors wrote: "Many pupils enjoy their time at Westfield School. Most pupils behave well in lessons. However, some pupils’ conduct on corridors and during social times is boisterous, disrespectful and not good enough." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/23/145562 | Google Maps

7. Carfield Primary School - Requires Improvement
Carfield Primary School was rated 'requires improvement' in all areas in a report on June 2023, after coming through what Ofsted inspectors called "an unsettled time". Inspectors wrote that children were "happy and confident." - https://files.ofsted.gov.uk/v1/file/50221393 | Google Maps Photo: Alastair Ulke

8. Bradfield School - Requires Improvement
Bradfield School, in Kirk Edge Road, was rated Requires Improvement in a report published in February 2023. Inspectors wrote: "Leaders have high expectations for pupils. However, they know that some pupils do not achieve as well as they should by the end of Year 11. This is because the curriculum over time has not been ambitious enough." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/21/146488 | National World


