What would bring people to Sheffield city centre - public toilets and free parking top readers' wishlist
Readers have had their say on what changes need to be made to bring people back into the city centre.
Like many cities across the country, Sheffield has been put into an awkward position over recent years.
Online shopping has decimated high street shopping, while cost of living concerns have seen more people choose to stay-in rather than enjoy a meal and night out in town.
So what is the answer to bringing people back into Sheffield city centre?


“Defo public toilets,” Martin French commented when The Star asked readers for their opinion,
“I had a conversation with a friend in Chesterfield a while back and she said that she no longer comes to Sheffield to shop with her mother as there are no longer public toilets.”
Many echoed this point, adding that over the years public toilets have been lost, forcing people to buy something in a cafe if they ever need to go.
However, overall comments kept coming back to something else - parking.
Tim Rudland wrote: “Better road access and cheaper parking in greater quantities. Incentivise people to visit independent businesses in person. The life blood of our economy.”
“Cheaper parking,” Norrie Ann McNamara added.
Clive Hague repeated the point: “More car parking.”
Countless complained about the city’s parking, saying that access remains the biggest obstacle to potential shoppers.
Some suggested that this has only been worsened by the introduction of the clean air zone. The CAZ was launched in February 2023. It charges older diesel vans and taxis £10-a-day to travel on, or within, the inner ring road. Older coaches, buses and lorries pay £50-a-day.
Jenny Baker explained: “For those of us in affected vehicles, the biggest barrier is the CAZ.”
Others pointed to a lack of options, hoping to see more activities in the city centre and a greater range of stores to help it compete with the likes of Meadowhall and online retailers.
Christopher Hague said: “More music events like the Fringe on Tramlines weekend.”
Paul Dove added: “Flagship stores. Not Poundland.”
While high streets up and down the country are struggling, other cities are still managing to thrive.
Manchester continues to boast growth, while nearby spots like York have been able to develop a strong tourist economy.
One commenter put it quite simply, suggesting the council take a page out of these success stories’ books.
Kay Manthorpe wrote: “Ask the council to visit Manchester and Leeds - see how it works there and follow in their footsteps.”