South Yorkshire reporter recalls 'dispiriting' miners' trials as closure threats destroyed a 'way of life'

A reporter at the time of the miners’ strikes has described the ‘dispiriting’ court cases he sat through during the industrial action that shattered local communities.

John Highfield covered the Dearne Valley area of Rotherham and Barnsley for the South Yorkshire Times when miners began picketing in 1984.

And while he mostly covered court at the time, he recalls a general atmosphere of discontentment across the region.

A reporter working at the time of the 1984/5 miners' strikes says that the threat of pit closures disrupted more than just jobs, it threatened a 'way of life'. placeholder image
A reporter working at the time of the 1984/5 miners' strikes says that the threat of pit closures disrupted more than just jobs, it threatened a 'way of life'. | Sheffield Newspapers

“You’d pass the picket lines all the time,” he recalled while talking to The Star.

“It wasn’t just photo opportunities, those picket lines were strong and always visible - no matter what time of the day you were out there the pickets were out there.

“You see this incredible scary footage of it all - the miners were on strike, the police were on the other side, but these were neighbours in many cases. These were people who knew each other.

“It absolutely tore communities apart. That’s cliché, I know it is, but it really did at the time and it took a long time for those wounds particularly to heal I would say.”

John described the strikes as one the most unique industrial actions in modern history, as miners fought to preserve not only their jobs, but their way of life.

“Even at the time I couldn’t understand why people so desperately wanted their children to follow them [into mining],” he added.

“But nevertheless there were people like that - they had lived all their lives in mining, their forefathers had lived all their lives in mining, it’s what identified them.

“There was something about mining that went beyond just being a job. It was a way of life and these people were fighting for what they saw as a way of life and a community.

“So it was really a very tragic time because that was all being dismantled around them.”

While miners did end up returning to work in 1985, that community never quite returned, and over the subsequent years mines did ultimately end up closing.

The effects of that year still scar parts of the region, and while work to modernise former coalfield sites with digital industry progress, it’s safe to say the effects of the strike will never quite be forgotten.

And looking back on it today, some of the most poignant memories for John are those he spent in courts watching strikers argue for their freedom.

He describes friends and family filling out Barnsley and Rotherham Magistrates’ Court to show support, and one particular instance where he braved the cold of December to travel all the way to Pontefract for a hearing.

“The one day I remember most is that Christmas in Pontefract Magistrates’, thinking this is just the most dispiriting thing I’ve ever heard,” he continued.

“They were just ordinary men standing in the dock - and they were shown very little mercy to be frank.

“It was a foregone conclusion what was going to happen and it did.

“I remember coming out of there just thinking ‘well their families aren’t going to have a happy Christmas this year’.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice