A consultation with the historic store’s staff is ongoing after the retailer announced plans to close, to a city-wide outcry.
The employee-owned company also plans to close seven other stores it says it ‘cannot profitably sustain’.
Sheffield Council spent £3.4m buying John Lewis out of its lease and renting the former Cole Brothers building back on a much-reduced rate based on turnover.
Sheffield Central MP Paul Blomfield said of the consultation: “I hope it is a genuine consultation with partners and leads to a reconsideration of what appears to be an ill-judged decision. They should stick with the Sheffield shop, which was successful when they signed the deal last year and could be more successful if they committed to invest.”
New cafe 'Joni' opening up in Sheffield serving varied range of brunch, lunch and breakfast options
Cole Brothers Sheffield: Grade II listing of former John Lewis slammed as 'ludicrous decision'
Sheffield parks: Gypsy’s Brew catering van to leave Bole Hills Park, Crookes
Mansfield Road fire station Sheffield: Landmark to become gym, café and climbing wall from January
Cole Brothers Sheffield: New future for former John Lewis department store is confirmed
A John Lewis spokesman said: “We feel it is inappropriate to discuss the conversation further. Our priority remains supporting our partners through the consultation process.”
Last month, executive director Pippa Wicks was quote d by the Financial Times as saying Sheffield could be home to one of 20 planned ‘smaller format’ stores.
And in response to a letter from Telegraph writer John Scholey, published in this newspaper last month, she said: “In considering the reopening of our Sheffield branch I want to assure you that all possible avenues were explored.
"The proposal not to reopen was a very difficult decision for our executive team, especially given our long history with your city.”