We went out into Sheffield city centre to ask the people who know best - the people who live here.
And while the answers were not always the most glamourous of the city's venues, they are places that they believe had that certain something that makes them want to keep going back again.
Some were in Sheffield city centre, while others were further out, in the suburbs. And the qualities that people raised as they explained what they loved about their favourites varied from the great food and great choice to the atmosphere at the place.
Here is the list of the choices - complete with the explanation for their inclusion.
5. Wagamama
Saffron Hall, of Richmond said: "Wagamamas. I like the beef broth meal, with a wooden spoon." There is one at Leopold Square. PIcture: David Kessen, National World | National World
6. BBs, Division Street
Tom Thickitt shared his views on Facebook after seeing our vox pop. He said: "BBs, Division Street.". Picture: Google Streetview | Google streetview
7. Sakushi, Campo Lane
Scott Bishop told us on social media: "Sakushi! On Campo Lane. My treat every month after payday I go for some top class Sushi and a bowl of Ramen. It's awesome." Picture: Google streetview | Google Steetview
8. Papa Ciccio's, Crosspool
Nathan Glave told us his views on our social media pages after seeing our vox pop. He said: Papa Ciccio's at Crosspool is the best Italian in Sheffield." Picture: Google Streetview | Google Streetview