Sheffield parking: Elmsdale Estates ordered to close unauthorised Sylvester Gardens site after losing appeal

A Sheffield real estate company must close an unauthorised car park, the government has ruled.

Elmsdale Estates, of Broomgrove Road, Broomhall, owns the former Bernard Works site at Sylvester Gardens, near Decathlon, which has been used as a car park since at least 2022.

The firm applied for planning permission in January 2024, but it was refused on the grounds it would conflict with sustainable transport, undermine air quality and ‘disincentivise’ redevelopment.

Elmsdale Estates has been ordered to close its car park at Sylvester Gardens in the city centre.placeholder image
Elmsdale Estates has been ordered to close its car park at Sylvester Gardens in the city centre. | nw

When it failed to close the site, Sheffield City Council issued an enforcement notice with a deadline of May 18 of last year.

On May 13, Elmsdale appealed to the government’s Planning Inspectorate.

Now, the Inspectorate has dismissed Elmsdale’s appeal and upheld the enforcement notice.

Elmsdale’s original planning application attracted 51 objections, including from Councillor Ruth Merserau on behalf of city ward councillors calling for better access to green and blue routes (waterways) for the growing number of people in the area.

The Sheaf and Porter Rivers Trust also objected, stating the Bernard Works site was the ‘missing link’ to complete a significant portion of the proposed Porter Brook Trail.

The Sheaf and Porter Rivers Trust says the Bernard Works site is the ‘missing link’ to complete a significant portion of the proposed Porter Brook Trail.placeholder image
The Sheaf and Porter Rivers Trust says the Bernard Works site is the ‘missing link’ to complete a significant portion of the proposed Porter Brook Trail. | Sheaf and Porter Rivers Trust

Chair, Simon Ogden, said he welcomed the Planning Inspectorate’s decision.

“The temporary parking has occupied the site for far too long, providing an easy income with minimal investment and this has probably delayed a better, permanent development of the land.

“We also understand that the site is now in process of disposal to a new developer with immediate plans for housing as well as riverside access which we would also warmly encourage.”

Elmsdale Estates and car park operator Bank Park were approached for comment.

Councillor Ben Miskell announced a city-wide crackdown on unauthorised car parks.placeholder image
Councillor Ben Miskell announced a city-wide crackdown on unauthorised car parks. | scc

In July last year, Coun Ben Miskell, chair of the transport, regeneration and climate policy committee at Sheffield City Council, said operating without planning permission was “not acceptable” and announced a city-wide crackdown on rogue car parks.

He said: “These illegal sites can block future development on brownfield land and have a detrimental impact on local communities.”

He also urged people to report cowboy operators.

“I’d encourage members of the public to report any car parks they believe are operating without permission.

“We’re committed to tackling this issue and ensuring land is used in a way that benefits everyone.”

In November, NCP left an unauthorised car park on the corner of Fitzwilliam and Milton streets in the city centre.

The city council had launched enforcement action after refusing two planning applications for the site.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice