'I'll never go there again' - driver vows to shun Broomhill car park in Sheffield after Excel's dodgy £100 demand

A Sheffield driver who received a £100 demand due to a car park systems fault said it had put him off visiting Broomhill.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

Michael Rhodes vowed never to use the rooftop site again after Excel Parking admitted a fault triggered threatening letters to innocent drivers. The company has not revealed how many - or produced independent proof the problem has been fixed.

Busy Broomhill has independent shops, cafes and restaurants - but limited parking.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Excel initially offered Mr Rhodes £60 by way of apology but he asked for it to be upped to £100 to mirror the firm’s own demands and donated to mental health charity Mind.

Busy Broomhill has independent shops, cafes and restaurants but limited parking.Busy Broomhill has independent shops, cafes and restaurants but limited parking.
Busy Broomhill has independent shops, cafes and restaurants but limited parking.

He added: “I'm pleased they recognised their error. But we only have Excel's word that their systems are working properly. Hundreds or even thousands of incorrect tickets could have been issued and may be still.”

And he urged the landowner to get involved.

He added: “I think the owner should take an interest because this could put shoppers off Broomhill at a time when many shops are struggling due to the cost of living crisis. I'm certainly not using this car park again and there aren't many other options in Broomhill so I'll go there a lot less.”

The rooftop car park is above a row of shops which includes Morrisons, Boots, Beres sandwiches and a Costa cafe.

The rooftop car park is above a row of shops which includes Morrisons, Boots, Beres sandwiches and a Costa.The rooftop car park is above a row of shops which includes Morrisons, Boots, Beres sandwiches and a Costa.
The rooftop car park is above a row of shops which includes Morrisons, Boots, Beres sandwiches and a Costa.
Hide Ad
Hide Ad

It is owned by a firm called Staghold Ltd, based in London, whose directors are John Lawson and Leslie Frankel. Tenants in the block pay rent to Philip Fisher LLP, whose directors are John Lawson, Andrew Michaels and PF Agents.

The Star asked the bosses of Philip Fisher LLP if they were aware of the problems, were receiving income from Excel - and how much - and whether they had evidence the camera systems were working properly.

The details has been sent to the parking regulator, International Parking Community, and the DVLA. Excel needs access to the DVLA database to obtain drivers' addresses. The DVLA can suspend rogue firms.

It is the third case this year where The Star has helped readers. Earlier this month, Excel apologised and paid Claire Blank £60 after an ‘administrative error’ at Berkeley Precinct on Ecclesall Road. And in January it cancelled a £170 demand sent to Louise Povey for failing to pay quickly enough, also at Berkeley Precinct.