Sarah Buckley is back, preparing to play her first pant villain opposite Matthew Walker in Rapunzel.placeholder image
Sarah Buckley is back, preparing to play her first pant villain opposite Matthew Walker in Rapunzel.

Why Sarah is back in the theatre spotlight after an 11 year break

She had only intended to take a break….but somehow that break turned into more than a decade away from the stage.

The year was 2014 and Sarah Buckley, then one of the most familiar and popular faces in theatres across South Yorkshire and nationally, was completing acclaimed performances in two classic musicals - Sunset Boulevard on the Isle of Man and Aspects of Love in Leeds.

“I think that was the point I realised I couldn’t have a full time job and do big shows in different cities all at the same time,” says Sarah, who is a manager with the NHS.

“It was quite simple - it just felt like the right time to take a break, though I probably didn’t realise it was a break that would last more than ten years.”

Theatre had been a passion since her school days - she was in sixth form at Sheffield’s All Saints’ School when she auditioned for and won the iconic role of ill-fated Nancy in Oliver.

“I was listening to all these musicals in my bedroom - Phantom of the Opera, all the big favourites - and singing along, which is what got me into it,” Sarah recalls.

“I decided to audition for Nancy and our music teacher, Hugh Finnegan, must have seen something because I got the part and it was from seeing Oliver that a couple of people started to have conversations with me about doing other stuff.”

That was more than 30 years ago and in the decades that followed Sarah became a firm community theatre favourite.

She was a regular principal boy in pantomime at Sheffield City Hall, appeared in major musicals on the same stage for acclaimed director Brian Platts and also took leading roles in shows at the Lyceum and Buxton Opera House, as well as appearing in Leeds, Stoke and the Isle of Man.

“My first pantomime I played Colin in Mother Goose and I loved it,” Sarah says.

“But then there were big shows like Children of Eden, Can Can, Sweeney Todd, Sunset Boulevard, The Scarlet Pimpernel, The Baker’s Wife, Footloose, The King and I and A Little Night Music - some really great parts in great shows for great companies at great theatres that I feel truly lucky to have played.

“In 2014, though, I was really busy at work and I simply couldn’t fit everything in.

“It felt like the right time after I’d played such great parts in Aspects of Love and Sunset Boulevard - Norma Desmond is one of the greatest roles in theatre for an actress and I was playing it with a brilliant company - and after that I just thought I was done.

“Doing those two parts took a hell of a lot out of me and I think I might even have done some vocal damage to myself - and then the older you get, the more scared you get so there was a real confidence thing going on too.

“The funny thing is that, having taken the decision, I didn’t miss it because I still had the same friends who were doing it and I was still heavily involved in going to the theatre, which is one of my big passions.”

The good news is, though, that Sarah is now back on stage, preparing for a return with a starring role in Handsworth and Hallam Theatre Company’s pantomime production of classic fairytale Rapunzel.

On stage at Sheffield’s Montgomery Theatre from January 28 to February 1, it’’s a new take on the story of the girl in the tower with the enchanted hair, her wicked stepmother and a handsome hero who will go to almost any lengths to save her from her from imprisonment.

It’s a full slice of post-Christmas panto fun, directed by Matthew Walker, who also stars as the colourful and crazy Dame Fanny Folicle.

So what has tempted Sarah to decide that now is the time to step back into the spotlight with her role as the manipulative evil witch Mother Gothel, who kidnaps a child, keeps her locked in a tower and selfishly squandering all the girl’s mysterious and hidden powers for herself.

“It was a bit of a combination of things that brought me back but I think you can blame Matthew really,” she laughs.

“I’ve always secretly wanted to play a pantomime baddy and this is very different to anything I have done before.

“Matthew kept nagging and nagging and asking what it would take to get me back and then earlier this year Neil Kirkman, who is one of my best friends, came back to play the lead in Handsworth and Hallam’s Urinetown and he also said it was time for me to get back.

“I have worked as an assistant director for Handsworth and Hallam too so I know what a great family friendly group they are.

“And my niece Myah, who is almost eight, is in the company too - and it suddenly just seemed like the right thing to do.

All that said, Sarah will concede that she is finding the process of being back in the rehearsal room quite daunting.

“It’s scary being back but at least I haven’t started having sleepless nights about not knowing my lines yet - but that will come,” she says.

“But I am quite disciplined and need to be organised and there are things now that didn’t exist the last time I was on stage - there’s an app for everything, including learning your lines!

“Funnily enough, the thing I am most nervous about more than anything else is the singing.

“It’s like being an athlete and I do worry that I don’t have the voice any more and that scares the hell out of me.”

And now that she has been tempted back onto the stage, is there any chance there might be more performances to come?

“What I’d really like to do is plays, developing the acting side of things,” she says.

“But right now I’m just enjoying getting back into pantomime and being horrible to Sara Ross, who is playing Rapunzel.

“She actually told me she dreamed of playing opposite me when she was a child - and here we are!

“I’m enjoying the challenge, I’m enjoying the fun of being a part of such a great company and I know that our audience is going to have a great time.”

For tickets visit https://www.sheffieldtheatres.co.uk/events/rapunzel/dates

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice