REVIEW: 2:22 A Ghost Story at the Lyceum, Sheffield
Who lives in a house like this, a famous TV show used to ask.
The clues are there…


Well it’s been two years since haunted house thriller 2:22 A Ghost Story last spooked Sheffield – and the clues are still hiding in plain sight in this spine-tingler of a sensation, at the Lyceum until Saturday.
Seeing the play, and its screamer of a twist, for a second time is even better than before.


The problem with a first viewing is you immediately want to go again, to be alive to all the dead-giveaways woven unseen among the clever script.
Watching it once more feels deliciously smug, as you pick up on each of the pointers interspersed as apparent incidentals throughout.
Penned by paranormal podcaster Danny Robins, the award-winning show opened in London in 2021 with West End girl Lily Allen as the lead, and has featured singers Cheryl and Jay McGuiness since.
This time, for the 2026 tour, it is soap actors James Bye – EastEnders’ Martin Fowler – and Hollyoaks’ Natalie Casey, best known for Two Pints of Lager and a Packet of Crisps, who take on two of the main parts.


Bye plays insufferable Sam, a know-it-all husband just home from a work trip and wasting no time in getting straight back into sanctimonious mansplaining, patronising wife Jenny when she admits she fears their doer-upper of a home might be haunted.
Jenny – played by Shvorne Marks – is on maternity leave (so could be forgiven for losing her mind) and feeling sleep-deprived and emotional. But can that alone explain why, for the past few nights, at exactly 2:22am, she’s been hearing footsteps pacing the floorboards of their baby’s bedroom?
Natalie Casey does an excellent job of acting increasingly drunk in order to play Sam’s erratic old friend Lauren, with a grating American accent and even more grating mannerisms, who’s been invited for a dinner party at Sam and Jenny’s renovation project.
Completing the tight quartet of a cast is Grant Kilburn as Lauren’s new tradesman boyfriend Ben, whose salt-of-the-earth East End plumber’s authenticity is welcome relief from the other characters’ pretentious gentrification.


The characters have all the self-satisfied cliches of friends whose university glory days were the 90s. The dinner party playlist is Groove Armada and Massive Attack, the wine’s a cheeky cab sav, and the conversation’s about kids and whether to have them, and bifold doors (and whether to have them).
The pulsating trip hop tunes provide the racing heartbeat of the soundtrack as the red displays of two frenetic digital clocks speed ahead or slow down, adding to the jarring, unsettling unease.
A giant fizzing neon striplight frames the excellent deep staging, and the frights – buckle up; there’s lots of them – come from your own imagination as much as the piercingly shrill screams of the London foxes that plague the couple’s foggy garden.
The play is as a detective mystery as well as a ghost story, with some interesting social commentary sprinkled in, and it’s Kilburn who gets to deliver some of the best, most common sense, lines.


There are chills, thrills, and a pulse-racing eerieness as the anticipation of a denouement builds against the otherwise ordinary domestic setting.
It’s funny, witty, and ultimately poignantly sad, and if you’ve seen it before the best bit is sitting through the jumps with ice in your veins – while your unsuspecting plus-one leaps out of their seat with every scare.
- 2:22 A Ghost Story is at the Lyceum, Sheffield, until Saturday, June 6.