And eyebrows were most definitely raised when they said that their first show would be a genuine Broadway classic - the gamblers and gangsters comedy Guys and Dolls.
What the project did have in its favour was that the new company had a venue to call home - the recently renovated Dearne Playhouse in the former South Yorkshire mining community of Goldthorpe.
And the other thing that nobody could deny was the joint enthusiasm of both Stuart and Frank, two men determined to bring shows to the stage at a time when other and longer-established companies are facing financial crises and even closure.
Stuart has spent a lifetime in Sheffield amateur theatre - companies including Phoenix Players, Croft House Operatic Society, Manor Operatic Society, Splinters, Woodseats Musical Theatre Company and Handsworth and Hallam Theatre Company.
Frank has a background in music but until four years ago had never been part of a show on the scale of what was now being planned.
Together, though, they had the experience and the enthusiasm to make a theatre dream come to life and to create something they hope will have a lasting community impact.
At the heart of the vision was the Playhouse itself, originally built as part of a Miner’s Welfare scheme that included a social club, two bowling greens, tennis courts, fishing lakes and both football and cricket facilities as well as the theatre in the 1920s heyday of the coal industry.
The theatre has its own place in entertainment history as the venue that witnessed the first performance by local lad Brian Blessed.
Brian returned for the official re-opening of the Playhouse in 2006, when it started to stage everything from from family pantomimes to tribute acts and dance shows.
More recently, grant aid of more than £3 million from the Levelling Up Fund and the Goldthorpe Regeneration Trust saw the 380 seat venue extensively upgraded, yet at that point it had been well over 15 years since the Playhouse had seen a full scale musical on stage - but that was all about to change.
Theatre manager Julie Medlam initially asked Stuart and Frank if they would be interested in simply staging a pantomime but that seed of an idea very quickly grew into something much bigger.
“We live just a short walk away from the Playhouse and from the first time I went to see it I remember thinking why is there a theatre like this here and why don’t more people know about it,” Stuart admits.
Frank adds: “We were asked if we’d be interested in doing a pantomime but we said if we were going to do something, we wouldn’t be doing it by halves!”
Instead, Stuart and Frank shared their idea of creating a vibrant new society that would produce spectacular shows and provide a creative home for local talent.
It might have sounded like an ambitious project but just 18 months later the newly-formed Dearne Playhouse Musical Theatre Company was on stage with Guys and Dolls, one of the biggest and brightest of the Golden Age Broadway shows.
“We wanted to think big because people always judge you by your first performance and we felt that if we were going to do it, we needed to do it right,” Stuart explains.
“Everybody thought we were insane and all the other societies, when we told them what we were going to do, asked us what the back up plan was - but there wasn’t one!
“The other question we were asked was why we were doing such a big production but I think that’s because they thought it was going to be some sort of village hall show and that wasn’t what we were planning.”
The Playhouse might be at the very heart of the Dearne Valley but as Frank points out, it’s only seven miles from Barnsley, seven miles from Rotherham, seven miles from Doncaster, seven miles from Wakefield and only eight miles from Sheffield, putting it right in the middle of a great catchment area for both talent and audiences.
“We decided we were going to do one show per year of as high a quality as possible, using the best costume company we could find, along with spectacular sets, and with the size of orchestra that each show was originally scored for in the professional productions, giving us the correct sound for the sort of show we were planning and helping us to recreate the magic of The West End” Frank says.
“And we decided right from the start that we would have the best production team possible for every production, putting together a show that would not only attract an audience but also be something people wanted to be a part of, something that was in everybody’s diary.”
The reality was, however, that the company started with no money in the bank, no funds in place and that meant having to find supporters who were willing to join the venture.
Nevertheless, Stuart says: “There were going to be no compromises because we were determined to deliver a production that our audiences would be proud of - and we believe we did just that.
“We not only brought together a great cast but we also had fantastic people working behind the scenes, including the front of house team, makeup artists, costume department, wig mistress, stage crew, lighting and sound technicians, marketing team and our great fundraisers.
“Frank was the engine driving the production forward, raising funds, building props, handling contracts and admin, attending endless meetings and sending countless emails and letters.
“It nearly killed the two of us - we probably did too much ourselves - but we did it and we survived even if people did think we were bonkers and I’m sure there were some thought we’d fall flat on our faces.
“For us, though, it wasn’t just about doing a show, it was about being passionate and giving something back to our community.”
Perhaps the best sign of how passionate Stuart and Frank still are is the fact that they’re now going into production foe their next show, evergreen Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice hit Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat.
Based on the classic biblical story of Joseph and his brothers, the show started life in 1968 as a 15-minute piece for a London school, before being expanded into a full-length musical that would go on to become a worldwide phenomenon, packed with hits like Any Dream Will Do, One More Angel in Heaven, Those Canaan Days and Close Every Door to Me.
The DPMTC production will run from June 9 to 13, directed by Ashley Booker, with musical direction by Jonathan Wilby and choreography by Karen Andre.
“Following the success of our debut production of Guys and Dolls, we wanted to present another show with the widest possible appeal and Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat is a timeless musical that appeals to all ages,” Stuart says.
“It’s going to be a great show for bringing a new generation of talent to the stage and we are excited to get rehearsals fully under way.
“We knew that we needed to do a musical that would get the community through the doors.
“We;’d looked at things like Oliver, The Wizard of Oz and Beauty and the Beast but then Joseph became available and with up to 30 children involved in two teams, we knew this has to be the one.
“We can’t believe how well rehearsals are going already and the amount of interest that it’s stimulating - we even had lots of men turn up for the auditions which, as anybody involved in community theatre will tell you, is always the hardest thing.”
So the show is up and running, the set is already designed, costumes are being ordered - and that again means the appeal for fresh unding.
“We are actively seeking vital funding through advertising, sponsorship, grants and local businesses, enabling us to continue nurturing local talent and entertaining our audiences,” Stuart says.
“This really is community theatre for the community and that’s very important to us.
“It’s already been an incredible adventure and when we look back to the opening night of Guys and Dolls there were a lot of emotions.
“But then, when the band struck up we looked at each other and thought wow - we have done it!”
Tickets for Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat are already on sale at www.ticketsource.co.uk/whats-on?q=Dearne%20Valley%20Playhouse

5. Contributed
The company's first show was an acclaimed revival of roadway classic Guys and Dolls Photo: Submitted

6. Contributed
Last year's production of Guys and Dolls was a hit for the company Photo: Submitted

