Review: Suspicious minds put to test by thriller

Murder Weapon, being performed at the Pomegranate Theatre, Chesterfield
Murder Weapon, being performed at the Pomegranate Theatre, Chesterfield
Have your say

Murder Weapon, Pomegranate Theatre, Chesterfield

Doesn’t seem much of a Whodunnit at first - more like an open and shut case.

A newly-freed killer is found standing over a body with a revolver, by the victim’s wife, Diane, and her best friend, the chief constable.

Old-school Inspector Fremont, called to the scene, is keen to get the case over with and the ‘killer’ Charley Mirren locked up.

But Chief Constable Jessica Bligh - played in great deadpan style by Claire Vousden, a veteran of stage and TV shows from Endeavour to The Politician’s Wife - is unconvinced and takes charge of the investigation, to Fremont’s frustration.

Philip Stewart is believable as the confused, mentally-ill Charley - who is put on the spot by Bligh - and doubts start to form, even down to the identity of the dead man.

Nothing is what it initially seems and the script has quite a few surprises - although suspicions about the identity of an alternative killer build before the end of the first act.

The play is initially quite slow-paced, as Bligh tries to tease details out of Charley, which are shown as flashbacks.

But things change after the interval when the action moves up a gear to keep audience members on the edge of their seats.

Charley protests his innocence, blaming an enigmatic character called Dr Blake - who doesn’t seem to exist.

A solid, entertaining piece of theatre from a seasoned cast, which keeps the suspense going to the climax.

One of the actors, former Brookside star Marcus Hutton - who was due to play both murder victim Paul and Constable Walters - was absent and had to be played by understudy Nick Barclay, who did a capable job.

The play continues at The Pomegranate for a further three nights – until Saturday, when there is also a matinee performance.