Injured player’s legal battle loss

Have your say

A FOOTBALLER who said his dreams of playing in the Premiership and World Cup were destroyed by a botched knee operation has had his hopes of a £10 million damages payout dashed by a judge.

Sharu Naraji, aged 27, suffered a ligament injury in 2005 which ended his career.

The former Sheffield United winger launched a compensation claim against US sports injury surgeon K Donald Shelbourne, who carried out a 2006 op to reconstruct his cruciate ligament at his Indiana clinic.

But High Court judge Mr Justice Popplewell refused to award the Bolton-born player a penny – despite finding the operation had been negligently performed.

Even had the surgery been a success, Mr Naraji would probably never have played football at the highest level, ruled the judge, who added in any event his claim had been brought too late under Indiana law.

Back to the top of the page