Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


BNP left up in the air

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 10 November 2009
I DON'T know if G Ellison of Dronfield (November 3) supports or opposes the BNP but it seems to suggest the BNP is, in fact, a far left party.
He or she states that the party is far from far right wing and that as the Tory party is a right wing party and is opposed by the BNP and states: '100% on mass immigration, Europe, privatisation and their utter contempt of British workers. Far right?
Far from it, complete opposite'.

So is he or she claiming the BNP is a left wing party, or what? I have seen very little in reports to state what the BNP stands for and what it would do in power, only what it is against. Nick Griffin certainly didn't have much chance on Question Time to say what he stood for.

Dating from the French Revolution those representatives who sat on the left of the assembly were the left wing and stood for The Rights of Man (to quote Tom Paine's work) and were anti-monarchy, church, and authoritarian control.

The right were supporters of the monarchy, church, social hierarchy and the aristocracy, The Ancient Regime.

Since then a lot has changed and the British Left claims to also have embraced socialism, control of free markets, racial tolerance and individual liberties; and the Right, unrestricted capitalism, anti European nationalism, cultural conservatism.

Now that the main parties have accepted, as a fact, capitalism, Europe, family values and a multicultural Britain where do they stand on the continuum?

It is interesting to adopt a model with, say, the horizontal axis ranging from Left to Right as we understand it and a vertical axis ranging from authoritarian to anarchistic. If we represent that as a cross shape and put the parties in the appropriate four spaces where would they lie?

Fascism and National Socialism were not identical in the 1930s but they shared racism, authoritarianism and nationalism and cultural conservatism with the Right. They did not care for individual freedoms and weren't anti-capitalist in practice.

New Labour isn't anti-capitalist any more but I maintain that the BNP can't claim to be a left wing party as G Ellison seems to suggest (he/she reckons that the BNP stands for no immigration, withdrawal from Europe, public ownership and workers' rights).

I don't think the old Left/Right distinctions apply any more and we need some clear unambiguous manifestos on which to make voting choices.

Mike Wild, S2

IF you want to cut through the smokescreen and find out what the BNP really stands for just read their website carefully. The rantings of the party`s semi-literate supporters are particularly revealing.

Name and address supplied



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 10 November 2009 7:01 AM
  • Source: Sheffield Star
  • Location: Sheffield
 
Prev
1
Next
1

Mosbroman,

sheffield 10/11/2009 08:08:43
Dont ever forget that the far right wing, fascist, nazi party had "Socialist" in its name!
2

Dave Farrell,

Sheffield 10/11/2009 09:29:03
Political ideologies are not a straight line from far left to far right. They are a circle where far right and far left meet directly opposite mainstream centre parties.
3

waywoodwind 47,

Lowedges 10/11/2009 11:24:12
Yes the BNP will stop this immigration madness and deport all illegal criminals from Britain

Yes the BNP will withdraw from the E.U. where the jobs for the boys and evil corruption is more rife than Westminster and our Town Halls

No the BNP will not deport people who have come to Britain to enhance their way of life and their families

But remember it was the Tories and Liberals who deported many of our own people to foreign colonies not the BNP

The Liberals as well as Labour have sent our troops into foreign killing fields to be slaughtered not the BNP

It was the Labour Party have destroyed our coal steel engineering and many more industries as well as given away all our north sea oil and gas as well as our north sea fishing not the BNP

The BNP will always put the British people first, so if that’s left right racist or fascism then so be it
4

Mosbroman,

sheffield 10/11/2009 13:21:14
Sorry,waywoodwind, your beliefs contain too much that is similar to that which millions fought and died to stop! Asking the BNP to protect us is like asking a fox to run the chicken coop!
5

SleepyHead,

SHEFFIELD 10/11/2009 13:48:53
> Yes the BNP will stop this immigration madness and deport all illegal criminals from Britain

You'll do it personally, or someone else will do it for you?


> No the BNP will not deport people who have come to Britain to enhance their way of life and their families

Even if they're illegal immigrants?


> But remember it was the Tories and Liberals who deported many of our own people to foreign colonies not the BNP

Because the BNP didn't exist until 1982 and the phase of deportation you're referring to occurred in the 17th thru 19th centuries and was abolished in the 1850s


> The Liberals as well as Labour have sent our troops into foreign killing fields to be slaughtered not the BNP

Because the BNP have never been in power.


> It was the Labour Party have destroyed our coal steel engineering and many more industries as well as given away all our north sea oil and gas as well as our north sea fishing not the BNP

And the 1970s conservative government and Ian McGregor didn't have anything to do with it?


> The BNP will always put the British people first, so if that’s left right racist or fascism then so be it

OK, well you define 'British' first and then we'll see what that promise amounts to, shan't we?
Prev
1
Next

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.